News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Richard M Stallman: Steam Is Good For GNU/Linux by Jach on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @08:13AM (#4316809)
From GNU.org:

> Specifically, free software means users have the four essential freedoms: (0) to run the program, (1) to study and change the program in source code form, (2) to redistribute exact copies, and (3) to distribute modified versions.

Not all these freedoms make sense for "non-functional work" like art. RMS outlines some of his views here: http://www.libervis.com/article/rms_on_the_ethics_of_non_fre... Paraphrasing, art (as opposed to software) is something contributed to society for enjoyment, software is for work. The minimal freedom of art should be shareable for non-commercial uses, with a max copyright of 10 years before people can create derivative works for commercial use.

I imagine there might be (or could be) a license that asks for the "source" of art assets; that is, a .PSD file, or a blender project, or a script that generates the image. That's a lot more useful to me than the final image itself, and a lot easier to modify if I wanted.

Re:Richard M Stallman: Steam Is Good For GNU/Linux by bmj on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @09:08AM (#4317008)
Paraphrasing, art (as opposed to software) is something contributed to society for enjoyment, software is for work.

How is a game for work? To qualify this, I don't necessarily disagree completely with RMS' aims for free and open software, but I don't see the functional distinction between the functionality of a game and the art used in the game.

Re:Richard M Stallman: Steam Is Good For GNU/Linux by Jach on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @09:43AM (#4317169)
Here's the non-paraphrased portion (which I should have just copied verbatim beforehand, I suppose):

"If you use something to do jobs in your life, you must be free to change it today, and then distribute your changed version today in case others need what you need.

"Art contributes something different to society. You appreciate it. Modifying art can be a further contribution to art, but it is not crucial to be able to do that today. If you had to wait 10 years for the copyright to expire, that would be ok."

So it's more that a program is a tool for work, such as simulating physics, running an AI state machine, animating skeletons, or rendering polygons, while art is just there to look at. You could argue that the game isn't complete without both, and you'd be right, but the art can be swapped out for random pixels and the game will still work whereas the code cannot be swapped with random other code. The functional distinction comes from software being breakable, it's a machine. Art isn't really breakable, it's just ugly (to some people).

If the physics engine of a Free game has a bug, users could fix it themselves and announce their changes in case someone else hits that bug--or even report it to the game maker's public bug tracker with a patch. There's also a factor of urgency involved that I didn't mention in my paraphrasing. If a game is broken, it needs a patch ASAP. If it's just ugly (to some people), that doesn't really need to be fixed right away. Plus if non-commercial modification is allowed, people who find it ugly can release "better" versions (which may be new assets or may be a hack to the game engine that adds new shader programs).

It does seem to get more complicated in the video game world where sometimes the distinction between program and art is blurred. In a hypothetical game with a completely free engine, I'd expect the non-free "art" to consist of base graphics that are manipulated by the engine. The manipulating code is free (and will work for any piece of art fitting the requirements it has, which may be quite restrictive), the input to the engine is not.

Re:Richard M Stallman: Steam Is Good For GNU/Linux by aidenn0 on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @12:43PM (#4318183)
I really don't get where the line is. Which of these are art, which are code?

1) A Windows Metafile (A list of commands to send to the windows GDI API, used to store images, but may also run code)

2) An SVG

3) An SVG that is programatically generated animated with Lua

4) A demoscene type demo

5) A postscript document

6) These postscript documents: http://home.thep.lu.se/~bjorn/postscript/

Re:Richard M Stallman: Steam Is Good For GNU/Linux by emillon on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @08:22AM (#4316833)
> I imagine there might be (or could be) a license that asks for the "source" of art assets; that is, a .PSD file, or a blender project, or a script that generates the image. That's a lot more useful to me than the final image itself, and a lot easier to modify if I wanted.

This is used in the GPL :

"The “source code” for a work means the preferred form of the work for making modifications to it."

And also in the "open source definition" that can be used to judge whether something is free software or not :

"The source code must be the preferred form in which a programmer would modify the program." [1]

[1]: http://opensource.org/docs/definition.php

Re:Richard M Stallman: Steam Is Good For GNU/Linux by icebraining on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @10:00AM (#4317244)
And also in the "open source definition" that can be used to judge whether something is free software or not

It can not. The definition are very similar, but they're still distinct.

If you want to judge whether something is Free Software, you need to read the source: http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.html

Re:Richard M Stallman: Steam Is Good For GNU/Linux by emillon on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @11:46AM (#4317820)
Totally agreed ; I should have pointed that this is only a guideline.
Re:Richard M Stallman: Steam Is Good For GNU/Linux by Jach on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @09:15AM (#4317043)
Ah yes, I've seen some art works released under the GPL before. Do many professionals do this? Have any lawyers looked over the GPL enough to see if there's really no hurdles with using it for non-software?
Re:Richard M Stallman: Steam Is Good For GNU/Linux by emillon on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @11:53AM (#4317857)
I think that the GPL uses the term "derivative work" which is quite vague when it is not applied to code. Many software distributions encourage their upstream to use specific licenses such as one of the Creative Common licenses to cover art.

That's true for text too ; for example most pages on gnu.org are licensed under CC-BY-ND.

Unfortunately, as the -NC and -ND licenses add restrictions, some distributions such as Debian don't consider it free software (cf. [DFSG]).

[DFSG]: http://www.debian.org/social_contract

Re:Richard M Stallman: Steam Is Good For GNU/Linux by 178 on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @08:19AM (#4316825)
Food for thought:

If there would be such a license, one could still argue it offers not the most freedom possible. To take it to the extreme, the license could ask that all assets have to be in a format editable/compatible with FOSS :)

Re:Richard M Stallman: Steam Is Good For GNU/Linux by betterth on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @10:43AM (#4317462)
I don't understand how someone can advocate freedom and also advocate any license at all. The act of licensing at all seems absolutely contrary to the idea of freedom.

As soon as someone stands up and tells me how I can or cannot use something, freedom is gone, no?

Re:Richard M Stallman: Steam Is Good For GNU/Linux by jiggy2011 on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @11:33AM (#4317750)
That's a bit like saying "America isn't a free country because I can't just murder whoever I want".

The GPL license does indeed restrict some things that could be regarded as freedoms, for example the freedom to distribute a closed source version (distribution only, you are allowed to create a closed source derivative as long you keep it to yourself).

It's a bit like "you have the freedom to do anything you want apart from restrict another person's freedom"

Re:Richard M Stallman: Steam Is Good For GNU/Linux by betterth on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @12:57PM (#4318303)
That's a bad analogy: America never promises freedom in her founding documents and constitution. She promises us Liberty, which is a very different concept than freedom.

In software, however, they are not arguing for liberty and the rule of law, they're arguing for true freedom.

I guess they have drawn a line in the sand and said that any less free is unacceptable, however, more free is also unacceptable.

Re:Richard M Stallman: Steam Is Good For GNU/Linux by jiggy2011 on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @01:18PM (#4318448)
I believe the FSF are interested in liberty rather than "true freedom" (at least in my understanding of the terms).

I believe Stallman originally wanted to call it "libre software" but there wasn't an equivalent word in english so instead he went with "free software" and thus the confusion was born.

The line in the sand the GPL draws is specifically for the purpose of preventing closed versions of open source software (which would be against the original authors wishes). There are of course more liberal licenses such as the MIT license which do allow you to do this.

Re:Richard M Stallman: Steam Is Good For GNU/Linux by Jach on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @02:53PM (#4319025)
This is basically the GPL vs. BSD/MIT/Apache vs. Public Domain debate. I've been on all sides at various points, currently I'm on the side of the GPL for "big stuff I want total copyright over (requiring people to sign copyright waivers)" which lets me change the license later or give out proprietary licenses at a fee. For other stuff that may be useful to someone and that I don't care about, I like the MIT license or the Do-what-the-fuck-you-want-version-3 license. If I don't care, I'll either forget to mention or it will be public domain.

The problem with public domain is that outside of the US, in some countries "public domain" is actually more restrictive than e.g. the MIT license. So if you want to help users worldwide, you either need to research local laws or use a simple US-law-based license.

The benefit of the GPL, as I like to phrase it, is that it chains its users with freedom whether they like it or not. It's a very viral license and infects a lot that it touches. (Some businesses are even worried that the GPLv3 is vague enough that "distribution" could mean over the web, which would make the AGPLv3 redundant.) If you look at Stallman's free software song, particularly the part that goes "When we have enough free software/at our call, hackers, at our call/we'll kick out those dirty licenses/evermore, hackers, evermore", you can interpret that as saying once enough software respects user freedoms by default, then yes, we don't need the concept of licenses anymore to force it upon them. The GPL uses copyright as a weapon, as do the Copyleft folks, as do the MIT/etc license folks. As a side quip, this is also similar to basic Communist philosophy: you just need totalitarian control for a little while to set everything up, then the government can dissolve itself and everyone will continue working together.

The MIT/etc. license folks subscribe to the idea that the more things you can do, the more freedom you have. While this is true as a single developer, if you again take into account the end-user freedom then the utilitarian argument can go either way. A program licensed under the GPL makes sure all users of that program and its derivatives are free, regardless of its popularity. A program licensed under the MIT leaves the door open for someone to take that code and put it into another program that's licensed under something restrictive, and all of that program's users are not free. However, some programs don't become popular precisely because of the (A)GPL, whereas an MIT project that's used in a popular project (regardless of that derivative project being MIT) often becomes popular itself.

So for the GPL, the total freedom utility is just num_users for the program and all its derivatives. For MIT, if a non-free user is as bad as a free user is good, it's num_users_under_free_license - num_users_under_nonfree. You can see what needs to be satisfied to choose one over the other. There's also a factor involved for profit if you or someone else wants to make money on the software without the risk of legal source-or-binary redistributions.

I think Stallman recognizes the tradeoffs as well, I've read somewhere he doesn't like but accepts the idea of software (such as video games) initially launching as proprietary while it's in its peak profit window (first few weeks for games, traditionally, though that is changing with DLC), and then later relicensing as open source. Same thing with dual licensing.

Re:Richard M Stallman: Steam Is Good For GNU/Linux by alayne on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @12:39PM (#4318153)
Society would fall apart if things weren't regulated. Imagine having no building codes.
Re:Richard M Stallman: Steam Is Good For GNU/Linux by betterth on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @12:58PM (#4318308)
Oh I agree, I'm just amused by people utilizing restrictive licenses to promote "freedom".

Can I do whatever I want?

Then it ain't freedom.

Re:Richard M Stallman: Steam Is Good For GNU/Linux by lmm on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @08:27AM (#4316855)
Read RMS on "the java trap" for an analogous situation in software. I think there's a consensus that it's worth making it possible to release GPL works even when they're written on a platform for which no Free tools exist.