Re:Apple Pulls Encrypted iCloud Security Feature in UK
by catlifeonmars on Saturday February 22, 2025 @05:59PM
(#43144179)
You have a point, but a major reason that the examples you cited above were kept secret was because knowledge about them was compartmentalized. As knowledge leaks, so does the possibility of whistleblowers. It’s an unstable equilibrium. My argument (which admittedly is based on an anecdata about how undisciplined large tech corporations are) is that it’s uniquely hard to keep secrets in modern tech companies because by design, knowledge is not compartmentalized. Modern large tech companies have replaced fiefdoms of knowledge with fiefdoms of operational expertise, if that makes sense.
Anyway, there have been hundreds, perhaps thousands of whistleblowers in the past and the examples you picked I think are representative of the upper bound, rather than the lower bound of the secret keeping capacity of organizations.
It'd be a huge mistake to look at the instances where somebody did come forward and spill a secret and assume that it means secrets aren't possible to keep or that there are no secrets being kept right now. It's may not be easy to keep a secret, but governments and corporations are extremely well practiced and have many documented successes.