Re:Suckless.org: software that sucks less
by gugagore on Saturday February 22, 2025 @08:14AM
(#43138718)
I thought it spoke to windows and macOS woes that package management was a third-party concern.
What is the gap between e.g. `apt` and Homebrew?
Re:Suckless.org: software that sucks less
by torginus on Saturday February 22, 2025 @08:47AM
(#43138918)
There are the following differences usually:
- Packages are useful units of software in homebrew, and both end-user apps dependency libraries in apt (and weird stuff, like headers, or dependencies)
- Homebrew packages are installed for the user, apt is system-wide
- Homebrew packages are updated and maintained usually by people involved with the software they are shipping, apt packages are usually maintained by the distro
- As a result, Homebrew packages almost always work and are almost always up to date, apt ones are almost never (stuff like go, node etc.)
Apt is like a weird frankenstein monster of npm, the system update, and an app store, and all that with a global scope.
If you want a newer version, too bad - your OS doesn't ship that so better luck in the next release. OR you can set up a private repo, and either ship a binary that has the dependencies included (shipping half the userland with your audio player), or they package the newer version of library, which will unwittingly break half your system, if not today, then surely at the next distro upgrade.
It speaks volumes of Linux package management woes, that no vendor ships anything analogous to brew or chocolatey.