Re:Show HN: Mastra – Open-source TypeScript agent framework
by anentropic on Thursday February 20, 2025 @07:09AM
(#43113743)
I think the problem is that a 'fluent' chain of calls already expresses a sequence, so the way that 'after' resets the context to start a new branch feels very awkward ... like a GOTO or something
It's telling that the example relies on arbitrary indentation (which a linter will get rid of) to have some hope of comprehending it
Possibly this was all motivated by a desire to avoid nested structures above all?
But for a branching graph a nested structure is more natural. It'd also probably be nicer if the methods were on the task nodes instead of on the workflow, then you could avoid the 'step'/'then' distinction and have something like:
e.g.
testWorkflow(
llm
.then(decider)
.then(
agentOne.then(workflow),
agentTwo.then(workflow),
)
)
Re:Show HN: Mastra – Open-source TypeScript agent framework
by calcsam on Thursday February 20, 2025 @10:17AM
(#43115706)
You’re right that the syntax was inspired by the desire to avoid nested structures. But the syntax here is interesting as well and fairly readable. Worth thinking about!
Re:Show HN: Mastra – Open-source TypeScript agent framework
by anentropic on Friday February 21, 2025 @05:46AM
(#43126122)
that example syntax is loosely based on CDK code for AWS Step Functions, since I had to write some recently
essentially you're building a DAG so it could be worth checking some other APIs which do a similar thing for inspiration
e.g. it looks like in Airflow you could write it as:
chain(llm, decider, [agentOne, agentTwo], workflow)
https://airflow.apache.org/docs/apache-airflow/stable/core-c...
How would you simplify this?