Re:Why the Number Line Freaks Me Out (2016)
by dhosek on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @12:33AM
(#43098909)
Not necessarily. If you assume an ideal ruler and compass, it‘s pretty easy to construct the square root of any number which means that you can easily put a dot on that number line which is provably not a rational number. There is the question of whether continuity actually exists (are time and space quantized like matter and energy or are they continuous? this is currently unknown) and the fact that your paper and the line on it are composed of discrete molecules. But if the real numbers are, in fact, real, then the probability that your dot is at a rational point is actually 0 since while the number of rationals in [0,1] is infinite, it’s only countably infinite and the number of irrationals in [0,1] is uncountably infinite meaning |ℚ|/|ℝ\ℚ|=0.
Re:Why the Number Line Freaks Me Out (2016)
by raincole on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @12:43AM
(#43098967)
You mean in real world or in math?
In real world, correct, assuming "dot" and "number line" are consist of real world materials.
In math, you need to define "randomly placing a dot" first, because it's proven there isn't a uniform distribution over real numbers ("pick randomly" is usually a colloquial way to say "pick from a uniform distribution.")
Re:Why the Number Line Freaks Me Out (2016)
by GrantMoyer on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @01:19AM
(#43099143)
Actually, the opposite is true. The rationals have measure zero, so a number selected uniformly at random from 0 to 1 (formalized way of placing a dot on a number line), has a 0% chance of being rational.
Re:Why the Number Line Freaks Me Out (2016)
by housecarpenter on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @02:29AM
(#43099579)
> it is absolutely completely impossible to randomly put a dot down on a number line and have it be pi
It's not impossible, it just has zero probability of occurring.
Right???