News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nuclear fusion: WEST beats the world record for plasma du... by gpm on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @04:31PM (#43095363)
Without any of the meltdown concerns a fusion powerplant is a lot simpler to actually build than a fission plant. It has a small fraction of the security, reliability, regulatory, etc concerns (not none, just way way less). Unless it's so marginal that it's barely producing electricity I'd be pretty surprised to find out we had Q>1 fusion and yet it couldn't out compete fission anywhere fission is practical.
Re:Nuclear fusion: WEST beats the world record for plasma du... by 00N8 on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @04:52PM (#43095598)
Modern fission designs mitigate meltdown concerns well enough that I'm not sure the safety & security around a fusion plant would actually be any better/cheaper, although public sentiment may be enough of an advantage. Tritium & neutron activated metals are dangerous enough to require keeping the traditional nuclear plant safeguards IMO. As far as proliferation concerns go, I don't see any reason you couldn't breed plutonium in the neutron flux of a fusion reactor, & the tritium is clearly viable for boosted warheads.
Re:Nuclear fusion: WEST beats the world record for plasma du... by gpm on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @05:47PM (#43096104)
Modern fission designs plausibly mitigate meltdown concerns well enough...

To move that "plausibly" into "actually" you have to have very careful design review by regulators. Very careful review of construction to make sure what is constructed is what was designed. And so on and so forth. It's a lot of friction that skyrockets costs. Legitimately. People inevitably attempt to cut corners, and there's no way to make sure they aren't on the safety parts without checking. Actual currently regulatory costs seem to bear out the difference between these, with SMR people spending large amounts of money to convince regulators they didn't screw up, vs Helion fusion being "regulated like a hospital".

I'm not saying fusion has no proliferation concerns. But it's the difference between "low grade nuclear waste, or a very high tech very advanced program to weaponize a working reactor" and "even a broken reactor can be strapped to some explosives to make a dirty bomb". I can't say I'm very aware of how much proliferation concerns drive costs.

Public sentiment also helps.

Re:Nuclear fusion: WEST beats the world record for plasma du... by 00N8 on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @12:51AM (#43099017)
A lot depends on the actual reactor design.

I was thinking more of large scale D-T fusion, e.g. the tokamak design, which requires breeding tritium & is expected to create a lot of neutron activated waste. The tritium is especially concerning, as it's roughly as deadly as polonium-210 & highly bioavailable in the form of super heavy water.

You're probably right for smaller aneutronic designs like Helion's. If they can actually be made to work, they'll be much safer.

Re:Nuclear fusion: WEST beats the world record for plasma du... by epistasis on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @04:44PM (#43095506)
That's astounding, I've never heard anybody claim that the reactors would be simpler before! Do you have any estimates of anybody working on the problem that thinks that?

Every schemer I have ever seen is quite a bit more complex than a fission reactor. Often, designs will depend on materials that do not yet exist.

That said there is a tremendous variety of techniques that fit under the umbrella term of "fusion," so I'm hoping to learn something more.

Re:Nuclear fusion: WEST beats the world record for plasma du... by elcritch on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @04:52PM (#43095593)
Not simpler in terms of technology, but simpler in terms of deployment, regulation, and security. Those are the majority of costs in fission power plants.
Re:Nuclear fusion: WEST beats the world record for plasma du... by epistasis on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @05:00PM (#43095669)
The majority of the cost in fission is in the massive construction build, change orders, logistics, massive concrete pours, welding, etc.

I've looked a lot into this in terms of how to get a project like Georgia's Vogtle to have cost less, or Olkioluoto in Finland, or Flamanville 3 in France. Big complex construction projects are expensive, and it's not clear at all to me that fusion would be simpler or smaller, or escape the rest of Baumol's cost disease that has been plaguing fission in highly developed economies.

Re:Nuclear fusion: WEST beats the world record for plasma du... by gpm on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @05:57PM (#43096201)
The more plausible looking modern fusion companies tend to be designing very small reactors compared to those projects. Vogtle is 5000 MWs. Olkioluoto is 1600. Helion is promising reactors that are 50 and can be shipped via trains by 2028 (or 2030 depending on how you read some statements/interpret what I just said). They still need some neutron shielding to actually operate them safely (boronated concrete, probably not shipped by train), but nothing on the scale of what you need for a fission plant.

(and other than that I echo elcritch's comments)

Re:Nuclear fusion: WEST beats the world record for plasma du... by myrmidon on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @06:30PM (#43096486)
Helion also promised 50MW prototypes by 2021. It's 2025 and they have no 50MW prototype still. Fusion power roadmaps are generally exercises in wishful thinking, while fusion power startup roadmaps are basically gaslighting-as-a-serivce.

I still think its worth researching and we'll get there at some point, but I'm not holding my breath-- the whole industry has overpromised in the past, continues to overpromise now and will be probably be irrelevant for de-carbonizing the grid by the time the technology is actually ready at an industrial scale.

Mass media reporting on the whole sector is admittedly even worse; especially for uninformed readers without an engineering background.

Re:Nuclear fusion: WEST beats the world record for plasma du... by gpm on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @06:47PM (#43096638)
I believe the promise you are referring to was contingent upon Helion getting funding that they did not get. It's not gaslighting to publish an amibitious timeline for a startup and be wrong, but that's not even what happened here. They said "if X (funding), then Y". X didn't happen.

I believe the current timetable is no longer contingent upon funding (since they've got the funding they think they need). It's no doubt still an optimistic startup timeline, a target, that they might well fail to achieve (even without the startup failing, just being late).

Re:Nuclear fusion: WEST beats the world record for plasma du... by myrmidon on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @07:02PM (#43096783)
Meh. They promised 50MW by 2021 in 2018. In 2021, they got half a billion $, but the 50MW plant is still not running. But the bigger problem is that those are all just pretty prototypes; according to a 2018 ARPA report, magnetic field compression in the 40T range is needed for commercial viability. The various prototyes have pushed this from 4T to 10T (and presumably soonish 15T) since 2014. Extrapolating that trend is much less promising than Helions roadmaps, and doing linear extrapolation there is probably doing them a favor...

It's a cool concept, but probably not gonna be viable anytime soon (if ever!).

Re:Nuclear fusion: WEST beats the world record for plasma du... by gpm on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @07:49PM (#43097147)
With regards to scaling, I think there are two components:

Does the physics change as they scale up the field strength? No one is really going to know until they try (unless we get a lot better at simulating plasma real fast). If not, they lost a bet, but they lost it honestly and as far as I can tell (not a physicist) it was a reasonably good bet to make.

Can they physically build the bigger magnets they need fast enough to meet their timelines (and everything else. I understand they are currently bottlenecked on capacitors)? Apart from normal "startups are overly optimistic" issues I don't see any reason to think that they shouldn't be able to reliably predict how fast they can scale magnet size, or be limited to a linear rate. While they are big magnets, it's not exactly new physics.

I'm not sure I'd say they are "probably going to be viable" anytime soon either. I think they have a good chance, but "probably" as in ">50%" is probably pushing it. (Also depends on where you put the goalposts of course)

FWIW I believe that 2018 report was for a high gain low pulse rate plan that Helion rejected, and they are aiming for substantially lower strength magnets as a result. I can't find anything more than rumors to confirm that though.

Re:Nuclear fusion: WEST beats the world record for plasma du... by myrmidon on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:14PM (#43097788)
Just to be clear: I'm not accusing Helion of being dishonest or even fraudulent.

It's just that from everything I know about the project, they still have a long way to go, and there are a lot of milestones to hit that are just pipe dreams for now (actually fusing He3, breeding it, net-gain energy extraction, ...).

I would expect progress to slow down significantly as the scale of prototypes and their complexity increases (like what happens for basically every engineering project ever)-- but progress is already slow/behind schedule to begin with...

Re:Nuclear fusion: WEST beats the world record for plasma du... by elcritch on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @05:07PM (#43095748)
That’d be interesting to learn more about. What I’ve seen always leans toward regulation driving costs.

Though I guess some of that infrastructure could be overbuilt due to excessive regulation.

Also much of the concrete and steel is needed for the containment domes. Fusion power likely wouldn’t require nearly as much protection. Perhaps just a fairly standard industrial building.

Re:Nuclear fusion: WEST beats the world record for plasma du... by bluGill on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @05:59PM (#43096220)
Regulation generally drives costs by making us build more. Generally safety systems and other redundancy.
Re:Nuclear fusion: WEST beats the world record for plasma du... by SecretDreams on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @05:22PM (#43095871)
I would guess the preventative maintenance over the lifetime of a fission reactor exceeds the initial build costs.
Re:Nuclear fusion: WEST beats the world record for plasma du... by beeflet on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @04:44PM (#43095499)
I think that it will depend on economies of scale.