News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Innumeracy of Intellectuals (2008) by barrkel on Sunday July 29, 2012 @02:31PM (#4309268)
The problem is that mathematics and the sciences are useful, while the humanities are largely about social signalling. One may be proud to be ignorant of mathematics precisely because it is useful; being ignorant of it indicates you have sufficient wealth in other areas that you don't need to get your hands dirty, as it were. And on the other hand, being ignorant of something like classical music is looked down upon precisely because it marks you out as not a member of the group.
Re:The Innumeracy of Intellectuals (2008) by aamar on Sunday July 29, 2012 @07:39PM (#4310182)
But there are reams of math and many fields of science (astronomy, paleontology) that have no practical utility. It's quite easy to find this sort of material in any university, in books, etc.

While I won't directly take on your social signaling claim, there are some humanities which have clear utility (while also functioning as social signals), for example knowing the precise meaning and usage of a large set of words. People in the academy are not disdained for having this practical facility.

An adjusted version of your claim: I think that in some countries (including the U.S.) math & hard science are tarnished through their association with poorly-protected and therefore indifferently remunerated professions, such as accounting, pharmacology, and engineering. Most educated people I encounter would, all things being equal, like to be good at math, but some let themselves off a little easy. Trying and being bad at history would make you dumber than a lawyer, which feels okay; trying and being bad at algebra makes you dumber than an accountant, which is humiliating--so better not to try.

Re:The Innumeracy of Intellectuals (2008) by hatcravat on Sunday July 29, 2012 @10:53PM (#4310704)
>But there are reams of math and many fields of science (astronomy, paleontology) that have no practical utility.

Really? Just how do you think ships (and airplanes while over water) navigated before GPS? How do you think the radius (and from that and the density, the mass) of the earth was determined? Would you be able to drive your car to work if not for the effort of paleontologists (many of whom work for the oil industry)?

Re:The Innumeracy of Intellectuals (2008) by aamar on Monday July 30, 2012 @02:09AM (#4311139)
> Just how do you think ships (and airplanes while over water) navigated before GPS?

All the astronomy needed for navigation was completed in prehistoric times, as far as I know. Modern astronomy, I think, has nothing to contribute.

> How do you think the radius (and from that and the density, the mass) of the earth was determined?

Eratosthenes modeled Earth as a sphere and the sun as an infinitely distant light source; what is the astronomy there, other than the common sense idea that the sun is very far away?

I think you could also have mentioned how astronomy inspired Newton's work, which has utility. But the point here is really about modern astronomy as a field of study: dark matter, black holes, etc. -- these are not "immediately useful" topics. Studying them does not get "one's hands dirty" because it's preparation for day labor.

> Would you be able to drive your car to work if not for the effort of paleontologists (many of whom work for the oil industry)?

Yes, I think so; a few paleontological techniques are useful for exploration, but it is not a major (or essential) tool, though many geological techniques are; exploration began far before paleontologists were involved.

The standard I was applying was really that certain fields of science are as superficially impractical as humanities like history or literature. A few paleontologists employed in industry wouldn't undermine that; a few historians get picked up by industry too (arts, law, etc.).

Re:The Innumeracy of Intellectuals (2008) by dmhdlr on Sunday July 29, 2012 @02:51PM (#4309322)
Among the Western public this might be true. But among intellectuals the bigger prejudice is that numbers are "hard." I certainly find them to be so, and have felt like this since high school algebra.

At root it seems to be an epistemological problem, complicated in higher learning by over-specialization in all disciplines.

Re:The Innumeracy of Intellectuals (2008) by zeteo on Sunday July 29, 2012 @02:50PM (#4309319)
Precisely. Maybe the best way to make math "cool" is to reclaim for it that status of "completely useless but fun knowledge" that Hardy was so proud about in his Apology.
Re:The Innumeracy of Intellectuals (2008) by jinfiesto on Sunday July 29, 2012 @06:19PM (#4309950)
Math is cool, and at least to me is lots of fun. The problem, at least at my university is that all of the lower division math classes have been commandeered by the engineering programs. I enjoy doing a substantial amount of recreational math in my spare time. Unfortunately, the classwork at the lower-levels (basically the calc sequence) basically involves regurgitating formulae over contrived physical problems. At its best, Math can be an extremely entertaining way to spend an evening, or a rainy day; It's at least as much fun as writing or reading poetry, or reading a good novel.
Re:The Innumeracy of Intellectuals (2008) by klipt on Sunday July 29, 2012 @06:31PM (#4309987)
Still true of some parts of pure math...