News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Discussion of HN at 4chan's /g/ by kstenerud on Sunday July 29, 2012 @11:19AM (#4308681)
That account hasn't been hellbanned. If it were, ALL of the comments for that account would be invisible, and would only show up if someone turned on "showdead" in their profile page. The site slows down all the time. Once again, that doesn't automatically mean hellban.

Most likely the system just lost that part of the thread. On a big site like this, performance is usually more important than data integrity, so the odd loss of comments is considered acceptable.

Re:Discussion of HN at 4chan's /g/ by Jach on Sunday July 29, 2012 @11:34AM (#4308727)
I'm very sure hellbanning doesn't affect comments prior to the ban--do you know something I don't?--but when new comments by that user are posted they are instantly marked dead. The slowdown is part of the hellban, the whole point is to make the site unpleasant so that the user leaves instead of coming back to harass. With the user believing the site is slow as tar and no one responding to them, it's quite effective. The downside is that it loses its effectiveness as it becomes public knowledge.
Re:Discussion of HN at 4chan's /g/ by kstenerud on Sunday July 29, 2012 @12:13PM (#4308830)
Interesting... I thought they did affect all prior comments. My mistake. He has indeed been hellbanned.
Re:Discussion of HN at 4chan's /g/ by kmfrk on Sunday July 29, 2012 @12:17PM (#4308839)
And as your comments show, the opacity of the rules and automated moderation is a problem with the way HN is run.
Re:Discussion of HN at 4chan's /g/ by hollerith on Sunday July 29, 2012 @02:40PM (#4309298)
It's a problem from the point of view of a writer wishing to ensure that his writings will be read.

From the point of view of a reader, however, having information about what will likely get moderated be scattered rather than gathered in one place decreases a reader's exposure to text written by people who have not read a lot of comment sections.