Re:Are PhDs losing lustre? Why fewer students are enrolling ...
by pinko on Thursday February 13, 2025 @06:30PM
(#43042817)
In many disciplines, it is almost impossible to get oneself into an environment anywhere remotely as rich in collective expertise, resources, and academic-social interaction as a proper graduate research program. There are exceptions (e.g., aspects of tech where money can be made, aspects of social science that intersect with public policy or activism, etc.) but they are rare.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Are PhDs losing lustre? Why fewer students are enrolling ...
by DrFalkyn on Friday February 14, 2025 @12:58AM
(#43045329)
In my experience Academia lacks the resources that corporations can give you. This has been a big problem in AI. The transformers guys probably could not have pulled that off at a university.
Re:Are PhDs losing lustre? Why fewer students are enrolling ...
by xanderlewis on Saturday February 15, 2025 @04:06PM
(#43062322)
You're exactly right. The ill-informed commenters here seem to think everything is about 'AI' and 'tech'. Of course you don't need a PhD to publish bullshit experiments on language models and unwarranted pontification — but try becoming a serious pure mathematician without a PhD.
But I guess the retort of the average tech bro HNer will be something like: 'we don't need pure mathematicians — just learn Rust and you'll make way more money'.