Re:Questions to Ask at Google-Fiber Announcement
by Stefan_H on Friday July 27, 2012 @02:01PM
(#4302710)
While I love the pointing out of logical fallacies, this is not necessarily an ad-hominem attack on the argument. I think this post provides important context for the reading of the article. Since I did not know of the blogger's background, this comment allowed me to put it into context.
Re:Questions to Ask at Google-Fiber Announcement
by ralfn on Friday July 27, 2012 @06:33PM
(#4303883)
That does not make any sense. Yes, arguments should matter by their own merit, but why would we bother with a list of arguments curated by somebody that is inherently a fraud?
With the same logic you can spent a full life carefully dismissing idiotic arguments on Youtube.
Who has time for that? So his comment is very relevant. The submission itself is tainted, and goes on the "maybe ill look at that, if i live forever" pile, together with racial arguments, conspiracy theories and the political spin city puke.
Instead, this is an appeal to groupthink to disregard the fair (and not-so-fair) questions raised in the blog post, instead of responding critically to them.