Worth also mentioning that the same time the 12VHPWR connector was being market tested was during Ampere, the same generation where Nvidia doubled down on the industrial design of their 1st party cards.
Also there's zero devices out there that actually deliver or take 240W over USB-C. Texas Instruments literally only released the datasheets for a pivotal supporting IC within the last 6 months.
If you're saying that the connector doesn't have a 2x safety factor then I'd agree, sure.
But I can see how the connector passed through the design reviews, for the 40x0 era cards. The cables are thick enough. The pins seem adequate, especially assuming any GPU that's drawing maximum power will have its fans producing lots of airflow; plenty of connectors get a little warm. There's no risk of partial insertion, because the connector is keyed, and there's a plastic latch that engages with a click, and there's four extra sense pins. I can see how that would have seemed like a belt-and-braces approach.
Obviously after the first round of melted connectors they should have fixed things properly.
I'm just saying to me this seems like regular negligence, rather than gross negligence.
The 16-inch Framework laptop can take 240W power. For chargers, the Delta Electronics ADP-240KB is an option. Some Framework users have already tried the combination.
A few years ago there was a recall of OnePlus cables that were melting and catching fire, I had 2 of them and both melted.
But yes 240W/48V/5A is insane for a spec that was originally designed for 0.5W/5V/100mA. I suspect this is the limit for USB charging as anything over 48V is considered a shock hazard by UL and 5A is already at the very top of the 3-5A limit of 20AWG for fire safety.
The advantage of USB-C is the power negotiation, so getting the higher rating only on circuits that actually support it should de doable and relatively safe.
The OnePlus cable melting give me the same impression as when hair power cables melt: it's a solved problem, the onus is on the maker.
Users needing the 240W have a whole chain of specialized devices, so buying a premium cable is also not much of an issue.
12VHPWR is 8.4x20.8mm so it's got 7.7x the cross-sectional area but transmits only 2.5x the power. And 12VHPWR also has the substantial advantage that GPUs have fans and airflow aplenty.
So I can see why someone looking at the product might have thought the connector could reasonably be shrunk.
Of course, the trick USB-C uses is to deliver 5A at 48v, instead of 50A at 12v
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USB-C#Power_delivery