Re:Show HN: Transductive regular expressions for text editing
by kccqzy on Friday February 07, 2025 @06:01PM
(#42978512)
I do not understand the rules by which you inject the epsilon and I think this is a source of confusion for many people. I had thought that an epsilon could be injected anywhere REGEX can appear (effectively allowing epsilon as a REGEX) but of course that just leads to infinite number of parses. Manually injecting epsilon is a highly hacky thing to do; better to consider that when you design the grammar.
I would not worry about "cat:dog:mouse" because intuitively it is clearly correct and it means replacing cat with mouse. With parentheses it could be written as "((cat:dog):mouse)".
Re:Show HN: Transductive regular expressions for text editing
by c0nstantine on Sunday February 09, 2025 @06:37AM
(#42990025)
Epsilon injection appears whenever right or left side of ':' has no operand. E.g.
(:a)
(a:)
a:|b
a|b:
etc
I will try to change the precedence and see how it works. Btw what do you think about explicit operators '>' '<' where '<' works as usual regex matcher, and '>' as a generator. For example to change 'cat' to 'dog' there could be something like '<cat>dog' where '<cat' part is a parser and '>dog' is a generator. Thanks.
Re:Show HN: Transductive regular expressions for text editing
by kccqzy on Sunday February 09, 2025 @11:30PM
(#42996959)
I think your epsilon injection rule is trying to achieve this kind of production:
TRRE <- TRRE ':' REGEX | ':' TRRE | TRRE ':' | REGEX | ...
I think this would work better, but ':a:' is still ambiguous: it has two parse trees.
If I shift it behind concatenation there could be another problem. E.g. with non-associative : should be illegal. And I am not sure how to treat this:
cat:dog:mouse
In the current version I inject the epsilon (empty string). It looks natural E.g. to remove every second letter I could run '..:' which is technically '.(.:eps)':
echo 'abcde' | ./trre '..:'
result: 'ace'
actually ':' association could have a meaning as a composition of regular relations; but I found it too complicated for now.