[deleted]
Re:Are functional languages inherently slow?
by nessus42 on Thursday July 26, 2012 @12:52PM
(#4297010)
> the author claims that C limits what can be accomplished.
No he doesn't! What he claims is that benchmarks are almost always chosen to be relatively easy to implement in C. What's easy and what is possible are two very different things.
OK, I've misread it, and retracted my comment.
Re:Are functional languages inherently slow?
by phren0logy on Thursday July 26, 2012 @12:47PM
(#4296977)
Note: I don't really have a dog in the FP fight. That said, your statement makes no sense.
The ubiquity of C does not mean that it limits what can be accomplished. Clearly, it can can be made to accomplish quite a bit, but that does not mean that it has no limitations.
Re:Are functional languages inherently slow?
by Deregibus on Thursday July 26, 2012 @01:04PM
(#4297138)
He appears to be referring to the writing of benchmarks. Specifically for those in which functional programming excels over imperative (for example undo support), it becomes a significant undertaking to write the C version so it just doesn't get done. This means that there is a selection bias towards benchmarks that can be easily written in C. These simpler benchmarks tend to lack any need for the higher-level constructs that functional programming provides, which FP advocates would argue is exactly where FP gives the greatest gain.
edit: slightly less snark.