News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anthropic: "Applicants should not use AI assistants" by logicchains on Monday February 03, 2025 @04:44AM (#42916580)
When you go for a job as a forklift operator, nobody asks you to demonstrate how you can manually carry a load of timber.
Re:Anthropic: "Applicants should not use AI assistants" by necovek on Monday February 03, 2025 @08:05AM (#42917814)
That much is true, but I've seen a forklift operator face a situation where pallet of products fell apart and heavy items ended up on the floor. Guess who was in charge of picking them up and manually shelving them?
Re:Anthropic: "Applicants should not use AI assistants" by oneeyedpigeon on Monday February 03, 2025 @05:43AM (#42916915)
Equally, if you just point to your friend and say "that's Dave, he's gonna do it for me", they won't give you the job. They'll give it to Dave instead.
Re:Anthropic: "Applicants should not use AI assistants" by eviks on Monday February 03, 2025 @04:48AM (#42916594)
You forgot a second sentence that completes the logic chain. Yes, "some tools are useful for some work", so what? That wasn't the original claim...
Re:Anthropic: "Applicants should not use AI assistants" by logicchains on Monday February 03, 2025 @04:58AM (#42916658)
The claim was that it's lazy to use a tool as a substitute for learning how to do something yourself. But when the tool entirely obviates the need for doing the task yourself, you don't need to be able to do it yourself to do the job. It doesn't matter if a forklift driver isn't strong enough to manually carry a load, similarly once AI is good enough it won't matter if a developer doesn't know how to write all the code an AI wrote for them, what matters is that they can produce code that fulfills requirements, regardless of how that code is produced.
Re:Anthropic: "Applicants should not use AI assistants" by skissane on Monday February 03, 2025 @05:58AM (#42917002)
> once AI is good enough it won't matter if a developer doesn't know how to write all the code an AI wrote for them, what matters is that they can produce code that fulfills requirements, regardless of how that code is produced.

Once AI is that good, the developer won't have a job any more.

Re:Anthropic: "Applicants should not use AI assistants" by necovek on Monday February 03, 2025 @08:07AM (#42917828)
The whole question is if the AI will ever get that good.

All evidence so far points to no (just like with every tool — farmers are still usually strong men even if they've got tractors that are thousands of times stronger than any human), but that still leaves a bunch of non-great programmers out of a job.