Thankfully most workloads are a relatively consistent pattern, so it is an atypical worry. The algorithm designers usually have a target scenario, like cdn or database, so they generally skip reporting the low performing workloads. That may work for a research paper, but when providing a library we cannot know what our users workloads are nor should we expect engineers to invest in selecting the optimal algorithm. Caffeine's adaptivity removes this burden and broaden its applicability, and other language ecosystems have been slowly adopting similar ideas in their caching libraries.
[1] https://github.com/ben-manes/caffeine/wiki/Efficiency#adapti...
There is no point fixing a "this could be slow if we have more than 65535 users" if you currently have 100 users.
I usually add a few pointers to the document on how to increase the scaling limit a bit without major rebuilding (e.g. make this cache size 2x larger). Those are useful as a short term solution during the time needed to build the real next version.
That project was the beginning of the end of my affection for caches. Without very careful discipline that few teams have, once they are added all organic attempts at optimization are greatly complicated. It’s global shared state with all the problems that brings. And if you use it instead of the call stack to pass arguments around (eg passing ID instead of User and making everyone look it up ten times), then your goose really is cooked.
When you look up the same value 10 times, you not only pollute the flame graphs and call counts which makes proving that a better algorithm is necessary or has any effect much harder, but more importantly, you could get 3 different states and try to make a bunch of updates based on what should be mutually exclusive states in the system. That's the global shared state problem.
When you look up a value once and remember it throughout a calculation, it may not be the current state, but at least you have a clean snapshot of the data. Which in situations such as cancelling an account immediately after getting one last discount on a purchase, well, we know which scenario the customer probably meant.
For this and other reasons I think that in addition to Functional Core, Imperative Shell, you want a “square” call tree in your code. Avoid functions with no fanout, and functions with high fanout. Rearrange code that uses the same data to happen as close together as you can, to improve local reasoning. When functions get unwieldy, or deleted code makes them too small, use the b-tree algorithm as inspiration to rebalance the tree.
Refactor when new features change the coupling of the code.
I think the only way to approach this problem is statistically, but average is a bad metric. I think you’d care about some high percentile instead.
> Caching is all about maximizing the hit ratio
A thing I worry about a lot is discontinuities in cache behaviour (simple example: let’s say a client polls a list of entries, and downloads each entry from the list one at a time to see if it is different. Obviously this feels like a bit of a silly way for a client to behave. If you have a small lru cache (eg maybe it is partitioned such that partitions are small and all the requests from this client go to the same partition) then there is some threshold size where the client transitions from ~all requests hitting the cache to ~none hitting the cache.)
This is a bit different from some behaviours always being bad for cache (eg a search crawler fetches lots of entries once).
Am I wrong to worry about these kinds of ‘phase transitions’? Should the focus just be on optimising hit rate in the average case?