The only reason the pay package is so astronomical now is because the Tesla stock has risen astronomically in value. Which benefits the shareholders, no? This dilution in shareholder value is already factored into the rising price.
Not technically correct. Tesla is allowed to gift Elon everything it owns. The problem was Tesla didn’t follow the rules in how to do it such that the shareholders were ensured an honest negotiation between themselves and management. The Board was not independent, and the shareholders at the time of the grant didn’t approve it.
A later cohort signed off on it, but it was still backdated. The only downside to making a new grant are the tax implications.
Musk was just sloppy and greedy. He could have got it if he had acted within the law, but then he probably wouldn't have gotten as much.