News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Even experts get it wrong by Symmetry on Tuesday July 24, 2012 @05:13PM (#4288033)
If I lure some customers away from my competitor by offering a superior product at a lower price then my competitor might complain that I "stole" them. They might say A: Stealing is wrong B: You stole my customers Therefore: C: What you did was wrong but due to the fuzziness of English words A and B don't actually imply C, since they used "steal" in different senses.

I think a far better word for these discussions is "trespass" as in "he trespassed on my patent/copyright/trademark". I think this has the advantage of being closer to literally true in a legal sense, more in line with what our moral intuition ought to be about for copyright, and giving the right idea about how the law regards the acts (copyright and trespass can be crimes if done in certain ways, but are usually just torts).

There are no comments on this comment yet.