Re:Think your dog can understand words? This scientist says ...
by cgriswald on Wednesday January 29, 2025 @05:05PM
(#42871831)
I think it is rather up to those making the claims to show that these stories are more than just selection bias.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Think your dog can understand words? This scientist says ...
by inglor_cz on Wednesday January 29, 2025 @05:07PM
(#42871861)
How should such a study even look like?
I mean, some people are perfectly fine with labeling other people NPCs.
Re:Think your dog can understand words? This scientist says ...
by cgriswald on Wednesday January 29, 2025 @05:31PM
(#42872129)
I don't think I would want to design such a study, but at a minimum arguments would have to be made ahead of time for meaningful pairings "outside-water" == "beach", all button presses would have to be recorded, and then a statistical conclusion could be reached.
> I mean, some people are perfectly fine with labeling other people NPCs.
Indeed. So whatever such a study concludes is unlikely to change people's ideas about dogs much.
Re:Think your dog can understand words? This scientist says ...
by observationist on Wednesday January 29, 2025 @05:46PM
(#42872285)
This is actually a study being run - https://www.theycantalk.org/research
They are recording button presses and sequences in both controlled and open situations, and have already observed a consistent capacity to chain multiple buttons together in naming a thing, and have found patterns in the names dogs come up with (I think they're also doing cat studies.)