News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nuclear fusion: it's time for a reality check by jmyeet on Wednesday January 29, 2025 @09:30AM (#42865279)
I agree with all this. People make two big mistakes when evaluating fusion:

1. The fuel is free to cheap, depending on the fuel; and

2. Stars can do it so surely we can.

So let's consider a mythical plant that costs $30B to build, has a lifetime of 30 years, costs $3B/year in maintenance and produces 1000MW of power. And the fuel. is free. Is the electricty free? Not even close. That's ~8.8GWh per year. No plant runs at full capacity 24x7 so let's call it 4TWh. That's about $1/kWh. That's ludicrously uneconomical. Of course you can throw in vastly different numbers and vastly different results but the main point is that fuel cost is a non-issue.

And as the article points out, in a D-T reactor, you still need to produce tritium because it's basically not naturally occurring in a way that can be gathered. That means a fission breeder reactor. That fuel isn't free.

Second, "the Sun does it" misses the point. As the article correctly points out, damage from neutrons ("neutron embrittlement") is a huge problem. Beyond that, it's a huge problem because every high-speed electron that escapes the plasma is energy loss from the system.

Stars use gravity for containment.

Re:Nuclear fusion: it's time for a reality check by jcarrano on Friday January 31, 2025 @09:55AM (#42888268)
Also, the power density of the sun is extremely low. A rotting orange produces more power per unit mass.
Re:Nuclear fusion: it's time for a reality check by pfdietz on Sunday February 02, 2025 @12:32PM (#42910128)
> And as the article points out, in a D-T reactor, you still need to produce tritium because it's basically not naturally occurring in a way that can be gathered. That means a fission breeder reactor. That fuel isn't free.

It doesn't require a fission breeder reactor. All DT schemes imagine a blanket where they breed their own tritium, and produce enough to start additional DT reactors. Some imagine a startup phase where they run just on DD for a few months, with Q < 1, to make enough tritium to start up. If fission had to be used to make all the T then DT fusion would be a complete nonstarter economically.