Re:HN's Daeken will expose security flaw in 4m hotel room ke...
by cjy on Monday July 23, 2012 @05:06PM
(#4283064)
It should be noted that [some] hotel doors with electronic key cards also have physical key holes (as a backup) that are hidden, but are still susceptible to being picked.
This just supports your point that hotel doors are not 100% secure for anyone who really wants to get through.
Edit: Replaced all with some. The doors at the hotels I worked had backup physical keys in case the battery failed. It's cool that Onity locks can be powered externally if the battery fails. Thanks for the correction.
Re:HN's Daeken will expose security flaw in 4m hotel room ke...
by daeken on Monday July 23, 2012 @05:10PM
(#4283084)
That's not really the case. While some of these do exist, Onity's locks themselves do not contain any physical keyhole and I've never seen them installed in such a configuration. Other vendors may be different.
Re:HN's Daeken will expose security flaw in 4m hotel room ke...
by Aloisius on Monday July 23, 2012 @08:21PM
(#4283706)
Agreed. The vast majority of locks on doors are to make the people inside feel safer, not to actually prevent a determined intruder from entering.
Given the dozens or hundreds of hotel staff that can easily gain access to your room, I fail to see why this is "scary."
Hotel locks with hard keys had their issues as well, and were pretty trivially picked with simple tools. But the key is always that you need to bring the 'simple tools' which is to say that they aren't vulnerable in a way that someone who decides on the spur of the moment to enter the room can easily duplicate. They need the plug that fits the power cord, they need the software which does the JTAG wiggler etc etc.
So if it is 'scary' that people who are not affiliated with the hotel either as guests or as staff can, with pre-meditation, open a hotel room door without damage. Then you need to re-define scary. This has always been true, and will probably always be true by the nature of hotels and motels.