Re:Caltrain's electric fleet more efficient than expected
by markerz on Friday January 24, 2025 @10:03PM
(#42819085)
Electric does help with getting cars to run quieter and faster though. With the old diesel engines, they needed more headway because of slower cold start times so there's more frequency and can hit the speed limit faster. Electric engines have high torque and are naturally much quieter.
Re:Caltrain's electric fleet more efficient than expected
by renhanxue on Friday January 24, 2025 @10:34PM
(#42819240)
It's not the electric motor torque that makes the difference. Caltrain used to use traditional locomotives, you'd have a single F40PH or MP36PH at one end pulling a bunch of unpowered carriages. Those locomotives were diesel-electric though, that is the diesel is only there to act as a generator while the traction motors are electric.
The Stadler KISS units are so much faster because they're EMU's (Electric Multiple Units), that is most of the wheels in a 7-car consist are powered with their own traction motors. An F40PH makes 3000 hp (2200 kW) while a Caltrain 7-car KISS consist can put out 9400 hp (7000 kW) continuous and about 50% more than that in short duration overload mode for starting. That's the reason it accelerates so much faster.
Traditional locomotive trains are completely obsolete in any sort of commuter service with frequent stops, there's just no way for them to keep up with EMU's or even DMU's. You can't solve it by just putting bigger engines on the locomotives, you wouldn't have enough weight on the wheels to make sufficient tractive effort.
Re:Caltrain's electric fleet more efficient than expected
by pm90 on Friday January 24, 2025 @10:24PM
(#42819184)
Yup not to mention that the fumes from diesel engines got into the cars so you tended to avoid the ones close to the engine. Its a HUGE qol improvement!
Re:Caltrain's electric fleet more efficient than expected
by stevenwoo on Friday January 24, 2025 @10:39PM
(#42819265)
Also makes waiting at either end, San Jose or San Francisco more pleasant with cleaner air to breathe instead of fumes if you are a little early.
Re:Caltrain's electric fleet more efficient than expected
by saagarjha on Friday January 24, 2025 @11:06PM
(#42819395)
San Jose unfortunately has the Gilroy commuter trains idling in the station :(
Re:Caltrain's electric fleet more efficient than expected
by arcticbull on Saturday January 25, 2025 @04:57AM
(#42820674)
For now. They're replacing them with battery-electric trains that can go past Tamien. Yeah, it should just have caternaries the whole way down but you know how rail is around here -- owned by Union Pacific, and the federal government prevents municipalities from exercising eminent domain to take control of railways.
Re:Caltrain's electric fleet more efficient than expected
by stevenwoo on Saturday January 25, 2025 @10:00PM
(#42827310)
I did not know that. I checked the schedule for those when I had jury duty in Morgan Hill and it was always never the right time and/or in the wrong direction, so I had to take the bus from the Diridon station to make my jury duty appointments.
Re:Caltrain's electric fleet more efficient than expected
by saagarjha on Sunday January 26, 2025 @06:02AM
(#42829306)
Yeah they only run in the “I commute to SF during the day” direction unfortunately.
Re:Caltrain's electric fleet more efficient than expected
by blintz on Friday January 24, 2025 @10:53PM
(#42819330)
Honestly, I think even the old Caltrain cars were pretty clean. The only dirty parts were the bathrooms (and honestly, train bathrooms are sort of gross most places). Caltrain has always been sort of luxury, though; the median Caltrain rider has a >100k household income, which come to think of it, might be one of the highest median rider incomes for a public transit system in the world.
Re:Caltrain's electric fleet more efficient than expected
by kccqzy on Saturday January 25, 2025 @10:50AM
(#42822316)
Apparently in 2019 the average household income of a Caltrain rider is $158,000. It dropped to $95,000 in 2020.
Re:Caltrain's electric fleet more efficient than expected
by Rebelgecko on Saturday January 25, 2025 @06:59PM
(#42826252)
I think COVID year stats are always a bit sus. I imagine the people who had the option of working from home tended to be higher income. Outside of medicine jobs, the stay home order mostly exempted lower income jobs (eg grocery stores, mechanics)
Not that electric isn't a huge step up for all the usual reasons but most of that is just because it's new and hasn't been worn out yet.