If you accept post-college compensation as a proxy for the value placed on educational credentials, it appears that, in the end, there is little extra value from, say, a Harvard diploma.
However, a quick note about the Harvard diploma. I have a bunch of Harvard friends, and they're really great people. And the one thing that's interesting about them is almost across the board, they expect to do great things. And this can be both obnoxious and incredibly inspiring. The overwhelming desire to change the world and (for some) absolute conviction that they will is something that I do think gets forged into some people in some institutions like Harvard. That very feeling can be worth it in and of itself.
The other thing I'd like to point out is that in general software startups (and the big guys like Google, Microsoft, Facebook, Adobe, etc.) that are hiring don't necessarily care as much about Ivies. They care about TOP CS talent. And that's Carnegie Mellon, UIUC, Berkeley, Stanford, MIT, Caltech, etc. If you want to start a company after college, you want to come out of one of those schools if that's an option. I think I've mentioned this elswhere in this thread, but your peers will push you harder and the competition is great. You'll meet super smart people who will push you to be better, and these can/will be your cofounders in the future. And cofounders will make or break your startup.
I'm agnostic on this issue, so I'll ask a follow-up question. What would be the value of credentials (in the form of a college degree) for a young person who desires to launch a start-up right after college?
The more valuable aspect of more competitive schools is the people you'll meet. It'll be easier to meet cofounders. People will be a little more ambitious. It's a significant effect -- it always helps to be surrounded by like-minded people who know they want to escape the rat race.
Also, the types of places that give you strong credentials are also full of smart people you might want to work with if you launch a startup.
Being at a place with smart professors doesn't benefit you much if you don't like them or if none of them happen to like you. Being around smart fellow students isn't so good if you don't get along with them.
Far better to find a dynamite mentoring relationship at a good school than to just float through at the best school.
I am very, very careful to avoid anything that might give me some preconceived notions about the candidate. If you think that someone is smart before they even walk into the room, just because they have a Ph.D. from MIT, then nothing they can say in one hour is going to overcome that initial prejudice. If you think they are a bozo because they went to community college, nothing they can say will overcome that initial impression.
Joel Spolsky, http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/GuerrillaInterviewing...
Think about a hiring manager who is less conscious of his biases than Joel. Even if he professes not to care much about credentials, will it affect him unconsciously?
I have Ivy-League credentials. Has this benefitted me ever? Yes, a little. Was that worth the 6 figure amounts it cost my family to get me there and put me through there? Nope. Not sure how well my experience generalizes, though. I suspect that I would've gained several times the benefit, had I taken some time off and prepared myself for college with regards to emotional development.
Still, I think it's better to spend that time and money in ways more directly correlated with gaining enriching experiences.
There was once an AT&T study that found the success of execs in AT&T was correlated more with how well the exec did in college, and not so well with which college he went to. And this is from the monopoly AT&T days, which is well within the heyday of credentials.
Because it takes more time to find the people that are more aware.
That's a good concrete suggestion, followed up by specifics. I suppose this would be a criterion to apply during admitted student visits.
Seriously, your most important experiences will be with people. The most important thing will be forming truly meaningful and effective working relationships with particular people. If you fail to do this, your college experience is wasted. If you do this in a half-ass way, you will only get a half-ass benefit. Therefore, your criteria should be focused on this.
http://www.paulgraham.com/credentials.html
Instead, the best thing to base your choice on is people. The next best thing is environment. Are there particular professors who you look up to who would want to mentor you? Is there a high potential for meeting the kind of people who will inspire you? Do you have good evidence that being in that environment will inculcate something valuable? (And starry-eyed reminisces of an alum are not good evidence. Lots of things can happen at an institution in a decade or so. Get current information.)
(Another way to put it -- the reputation of a school is marketing. Doesn't it seem wise to corroborate that with more direct measures of value?)