News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The alluring danger of dilettantism by tptacek on Saturday January 10, 2009 @12:45PM (#428073)
This is a really dumb article. Guitar Hero is popular in large part because it is social. One person might want to learn a guitar. A whole room full of buzzed people do not. I can think of few things less social than sitting in a room developing callouses while trying to nail barre chords.

My brother is a professional guitarist, and he's the one that brings (well, Rock Band) on the holidays.

What's the rest of the evidence that society is avoiding difficulty? Are fewer people becoming doctors or engineers?

Re:The alluring danger of dilettantism by sofal on Saturday January 10, 2009 @02:13PM (#428204)
I can say from my experience that while it's not Guitar Hero or Rock Band that keeps me from practicing guitar, the author's example of psychedelic music is an apt one. The sheer amount of guitar material available to me is almost paralyzing. There really is no scarcity to help motivate me. I'm borrowing my friend's guitar and he burned a couple instructional DVDs for me. There are tabs online for just about any song you can think of. There are hundreds of instructional and example videos on YouTube. When I plug the guitar into my Mac I've already got a little recording studio and an amp with more settings than I care to know about and 30 different guitars.

It's never been easier to learn guitar. Except that for some reason the ease of it all makes me take it for granted and even makes me bored. I'm just a quick search away from hundreds of videos of people who play better than I could ever hope to. Sometimes it feels like everyone and their dog already knows how to play except for me. While I ponder the futility of it, I get distracted by all the other neat stuff that I can learn.

I have to consciously fight laziness. There are so many easy and fun things to do nowadays that it takes some extra discipline to focus. I like to think I'm succeeding. Sometimes I start out working on my personal project and then a little while later here I am responding to someone's interesting comment on an interesting article.

There is an interesting problem in a society like this. I've lost too many friends and family to World of Warcraft to deny it. Perhaps it's not worse than the problems faced by earlier generations, but it's definitely different.

Re:The alluring danger of dilettantism by tptacek on Saturday January 10, 2009 @03:03PM (#428258)
This is why there are guitar teachers, right?
Re:The alluring danger of dilettantism by rms on Saturday January 10, 2009 @06:44PM (#428545)
Yeah... you aren't supposed to learn how to play music by yourself.
Re:The alluring danger of dilettantism by time_management on Saturday January 10, 2009 @01:55PM (#428172)
What's the rest of the evidence that society is avoiding difficulty? Are fewer people becoming doctors or engineers?

For a while, a lot of talented people were piling into the financial industry, which is (was?) the only industry in which it's possible to be entirely mediocre and make $1m/year within a decade. The horrific collapse of the academic job market was a contributor to this trend.

However, I don't think the desire to make large sums of money with modest effort is a new feature of our "hyperdiverse" economy. It's a rather mundane result of human nature.

Re:The alluring danger of dilettantism by tptacek on Saturday January 10, 2009 @03:02PM (#428257)
A lot of those people were only going into EECS to make easy money too; many of them were only going to stay for 2-5 years before coming back for an MBA or a law degree to go after IP law.

I guess the simple question is, are there fewer people going in to medicine now? It's incredibly difficult to become a doctor.