Re:A Skeptic Looks at Alternative Energy
by mc32 on Monday July 23, 2012 @01:21AM
(#4279655)
> NASA scientists also thought we'd be going to Mars by 2025. What does that prove?
We don't _have_ to go to Mars tomorrow. We _do_ need energy right now. Panel prices have fallen through the floor, but panels are only one component in the PV energy production cycle. He cites that residential PV production cost per kW/h hasn't changed significantly since the 2000's. (~¢30 sunny and ~¢60 cloudy areas) traditional production means average 11 to ¢12 kW/h.
>A number of U.S. states are seeing immediate local benefits from supplying > 10% of their electricity through wind power.
That's definitely a positive outcome, but an investment in anything will bring jobs (tearing up roads and repaving). I think he's trying to find out it it makes economic sense to invest in wind power versus something else. I think it's debatable, at least. He might be proven wrong, but so might others.
>I'm not quite sure why "% of global electricity consumption" is the only salient metric
I think it's because his main point is about trying to prevent going over the 450ppm of CO2 in the atmosphere --which isn't regionally manifested but globally manifested.
We don't _have_ to go to Mars tomorrow. We _do_ need energy right now. Panel prices have fallen through the floor, but panels are only one component in the PV energy production cycle. He cites that residential PV production cost per kW/h hasn't changed significantly since the 2000's. (~¢30 sunny and ~¢60 cloudy areas) traditional production means average 11 to ¢12 kW/h.
>A number of U.S. states are seeing immediate local benefits from supplying > 10% of their electricity through wind power.
That's definitely a positive outcome, but an investment in anything will bring jobs (tearing up roads and repaving). I think he's trying to find out it it makes economic sense to invest in wind power versus something else. I think it's debatable, at least. He might be proven wrong, but so might others.
>I'm not quite sure why "% of global electricity consumption" is the only salient metric
I think it's because his main point is about trying to prevent going over the 450ppm of CO2 in the atmosphere --which isn't regionally manifested but globally manifested.