News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:App.net 3rd-party revshare proposal by tptacek on Sunday July 22, 2012 @06:21PM (#4278700)
Without implying that I endorse this idea, which I think will fail simply due to network effects, it's a tiresome argument that says App.net doesn't have value to end-users because end-users don't care about ads.

It's true, as the argument says, that end-users won't care enough about Twitter's ads over the next year or two to abandon the service for a competitor. The ads themselves are just not that big of a deal.

But the need to draw revenue from ads is causing Twitter to make decisions that harm third-party developers. End-users don't care about third-party developers, but they very well might care about applications; if alterna-Twitter enables applications that users care about, the plight of developers or insidiousness of ads won't have to matter, because it'll be the apps themselves that sell the service.

Re:App.net 3rd-party revshare proposal by kyro on Sunday July 22, 2012 @08:05PM (#4278932)
I think that works in theory, but you have to look at what will draw users to care about applications. If the network effects aren't there, there's no reason why a user would be drawn to using a given application if the underlying service just isn't worth it. Users have a high tolerance for bad design and I think not paying for a Twitter that displays ads is well within that range of tolerance with the current Twitter app offerings.

You'd have to not charge users to get the network effects to kick in, but at that point, you're just a more open Twitter clone and you'll have to scramble to find a revenue source eventually.

Re:App.net 3rd-party revshare proposal by dinkumthinkum on Monday July 23, 2012 @01:18AM (#4279646)
An argument being tiresome doesn't speak to it being wrong, though. One big issue I see here is that, what if Twitter stopped being mean to developers? Eek. What if they also make ads less obtrusive ... Game over?