Re:App.net 3rd-party revshare proposal
by dinkumthinkum on Monday July 23, 2012 @01:25AM
(#4279670)
I think I agree with you. The more I look at it, I just don't see it. When I first heard about it, I had this feeling I really wanted it to succeed but then I didn't know what really way. Then I found out it is like this Twitter alternative, but I don't like Twitter. I don't like the concept of Twitter, I don't like its effect on society, on language, on communication. So, whatever, but I don't know if I would like this. Nevertheless, it could be, if it worked, a good step in a particular direction for social networking. However, again, I agree, I don't see how it could work.
But you know, it might be good to have an example of someone actually trying this and failing, so we don't have to just hypothesize that it will fail?
Even if you get geeks on board as your early adopters, you're still going to miss out on the much larger non-geek demographic that make these social networks what they are, even to geeks. Remember, you're going for a social tool here, and so you'll need to make it easy for a person's entire social circle to join else it'll be rendered useless. If you're trying to position this as dev-centric alone and to foster a github-like community around dev topics, then I could see this working. But as a catch-all social network, I don't think this will take off.
I commend you for trying, of course. Definitely a lot gutsier than I am to take on such a bold endeavor.