You have to be pretty good to pick individual stocks which will perform well on a 70 year timeline. Are there even more then 20 companies that have been publicly traded in the US for that long?
Re:Our Ridiculous Approach to Retirement
by mynameishere on Sunday July 22, 2012 @02:24PM
(#4278070)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dow_Jones_Industrial_Average#Hi...
If you bought the original djia in 1896 and were still alive you'd be very wealthy.
okay, okay, i got your point. Yes as long as the fund is a really low fee one, like Vanguard's ones with around $10 per $10000 a year invested, that's nearly an equivalent to a stock market minus the pain of balancing the portfolio yourself.
But again, that really means nothing compared to the fact that people don't really save at all. I know a lot of people of my age (early 30s) for who the phrase 'got no money' means 'maxed out all of my credit cards and can't get a new one'. Some of them are MBAs so it's not about financial literacy.
Social security, pensions etc. - agree, these are on the way out due to demographic changes. But that's a point for individual retirement savings, not against them.
And yes, there is no such thing as stock performance prediction, this has been proven many times since the 1930s. So funds are useless in the long run - just a way to trade performance for risks, and pay a fee (while i agree that in the case of Vanguard, you lose almost nothing because the fund is really cheap).