News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by corobo on Monday January 20, 2025 @09:57PM (#42775967)
Isn't that literally what copyright is?

You have bought the text so you have the readright, but you do not the copyright.

Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by gruez on Monday January 20, 2025 @10:27PM (#42776201)
>You have bought the text so you have the readright, but you do not the copyright.

You do however, have the right to make derivative works based on the contents of the book. You reading a physics textbook doesn't mean you can't write a blog post about gravity or whatever, and you reading harry potter doesn't mean you can't write a series of fantasy books involving a young wizard trying to fight an evil wizard.

Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by yencabulator on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @09:27AM (#42780429)
Last I looked, machines are considered unable to create copyrightable content, so your attempt to compare that to LLMs might not work in court.

> The application was denied because, based on the applicant’s representations in the application, the examiner found that the work contained no human authorship. After a series of administrative appeals, the Office’s Review Board issued a final determination affirming that the work could not be registered because it was made “without any creative contribution from a human actor.”

https://www.copyright.gov/ai/ai_policy_guidance.pdf

Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by gruez on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @11:42AM (#42782143)
>Last I looked, machines are considered unable to create copyrightable content, so your attempt to compare that to LLMs might not work in court.

That just means whatever they produce can't be copyrighted, not that they can't produce derivative works. Courts have upheld the right for google to produce thumbnails of copyrighted works, even though the procedure for producing thumbnails is done by a computer and thus can't be copyrighted.

Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by furyofantares on Monday January 20, 2025 @10:36PM (#42776288)
Sure, which is a thing we've sort of agreed on as a society based on human consumption and creativity. Not that we all agree, and not that this agreement is free of influence from megacorps. But the context in which we've enacted copyright law is based on values related to human consumption and creativity.

Maybe we will end up agreeing that we just want to stick with those same laws for machine consumption and creativity. But maybe we won't since they are quite different things.