News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Say 'Ahhh': A Simpler Way To Detect Parkinson's by blahedo on Sunday July 22, 2012 @01:47AM (#4276566)
One big issue with gathering this kind of data over the phone is the frequency cutoff on voice-only lines—above a certain frequency (I want to say 4kHz? maybe I'm misremembering), the information is lost. It's basically as if you took a Fourier transform, zeroed out everything above the threshold, and then transformed back.[0] For humans (and even computers) trying to interpret the sound as language, that's not a huge problem, although you might lose some of the higher formants. But for an acoustic analysis that's trying to do voiceprinting—in this case to detect Parkinson's—this could be a big problem.

(I'm also irritated by the glib "99 percent success rate" but I just ranted about that on a different HN post so I won't go into it here.)

[0] Why do this? So the phone company can compress and send a lot more data over the same amount of internal bandwidth. Come to think of it, it's kind of related to how wavelet-based compression works.

Re:Say 'Ahhh': A Simpler Way To Detect Parkinson's by rachelbythebay on Sunday July 22, 2012 @03:35AM (#4276709)
8 bits, 8 kHz. There's only so much you can do with that.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DS0

Sure, we can do more now, but this isn't exactly new. Consider the age in which it was conceived and it may seem more reasonable.

Re:Say 'Ahhh': A Simpler Way To Detect Parkinson's by NinetyNine on Sunday July 22, 2012 @05:14AM (#4276865)
The sampling frequency doesn't directly effect the audio frequencies it can encode. Telephones do PCM encoding (meaning it has data representing the graph of the sound wave) at 8 kh/z. Following the nyquist sampling theorem (cut your rate by 2), this can allow frequencies up to 4 kh/z (as you said). It's not a hard cutoff though, you can still get most of the sounds above that pitch, they'll just sound pretty weird (as if you were talking on the telephone!)
Re:Say 'Ahhh': A Simpler Way To Detect Parkinson's by lgeek on Sunday July 22, 2012 @09:30AM (#4277277)
No, components above the Nyquist frequency are filtered out before the ADC because you'd otherwise get aliasing.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aliasing

Re:Say 'Ahhh': A Simpler Way To Detect Parkinson's by ableal on Sunday July 22, 2012 @07:05AM (#4277047)
> So the phone company can compress and send a lot more data

Actually, the limits date back to analog phone lines with circuit switching of a century ago. Back then there was a wire going through switches from one phone to another. The quality requirements were that those lines had to pass 300 Hz to 3.4 kHz or so. That often required "pupinization" - adding inductive coils to tune the line's frequency response.

If you look at a spectrogram of your voice, there's very little power above 1.5 or 2 kHz. However, it seems the high frequency part is important to understandability, including perception of emotional overtones.

(Just the other day, playing with modems, we found a weird case - voice being pumped through before the call was considered completed - which I suspect is the persistence in digital protocols of the analog behavior of a century ago.)