News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by ori_b on Saturday July 21, 2012 @11:43PM (#4276382)
In violation of a court order. This shouldn't come as a surprise. Regardless of whether she's right or wrong, this is a decision where the price was clear. It was her choice to pay it.
Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by chris_wot on Sunday July 22, 2012 @12:14AM (#4276426)
If it's violating her first amendment rights, then the court order is in violation of the first amendment!
Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by boboblong on Sunday July 22, 2012 @01:30AM (#4276543)
Courts issue gag orders all the time and have done so for centuries. They can be constitutional.
Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by chris_wot on Sunday July 22, 2012 @04:06AM (#4276759)
Not normally against the plaintiff when the accused if found guilty!
Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by taligent on Sunday July 22, 2012 @05:56AM (#4276923)
These are children we are talking about.

It IS normal for their names not to be released. Do you not watch the news ?

Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by recursive on Sunday July 22, 2012 @01:24AM (#4276532)

    this is a decision where the price was clear
I think people are talking about whether the price was appropriate and warranted.
Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by ori_b on Sunday July 22, 2012 @01:54AM (#4276583)
My point is that she knew what it was beforehand. She did a cost benefit analysis, and decided she was willing to pay it.
Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by kenjackson on Sunday July 22, 2012 @02:02AM (#4276593)
She's a juvenile. Maybe her sentence will be as lenient as the rapists... I doubt it.
Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by heretohelp on Sunday July 22, 2012 @12:03AM (#4276410)
Why is there always a comment from the legal fatalism gallery in every HN thread like this? Can we not strive for victim's rights or for more human policy-making?

Beyond that, it's annoying, obvious, and contributes nothing.

Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by codex on Sunday July 22, 2012 @01:38AM (#4276555)
Legal fatalism is one of the few responsible comments one can make about a case like this. We don'k know much about the case--the facts are sealed, and we have no context--and I'm not willing to second guess a judge based on one sided, incomplete, inflammatory comments leaked by an angry first-party. But by all means, pass judgement and cast the first stone yourselves. It wouldn't be the first time vigilante justice has been performed.
Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by mikescar on Sunday July 22, 2012 @02:54AM (#4276657)
Well, we know that they both pled guilty. That's publicly available.

Other than that major point, we don't have context. Yes, I would like everything to be public so we know what we're paying for.

I'm going to 'pass judgement', and leave you to responsible commenting.

Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by nkurz on Sunday July 22, 2012 @04:45AM (#4276825)
Here are two cases where rape defendants chose to plead guilty to a crimes they did not commit:

http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/readme/2002/...

http://ratiojuris.blogspot.com/2012/05/when-innocent-clients...

I presume that such cases are a minority, that those who plead guilty generally are. But I don't know what the actual odds are. What makes you certain? Or are you comfortable passing judgement regardless?

Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by mikescar on Sunday July 22, 2012 @09:51PM (#4279202)
Yes, it has happened.

I'm comfortable forming an opinion based on the facts available. As I said in my comment, I'd like more info since it's ostensibly a public function to run a government court.

Otherwise we can all just run around with our hands in the air crying about how we just can't make a decision on anything in which we weren't directly a party.

Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by capitao on Sunday July 22, 2012 @06:36AM (#4277005)
Yeaaaah this isn't one of those cases, I'm pretty comfortable judging on this one
Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by Danieru on Sunday July 22, 2012 @12:52AM (#4276492)
Naming people on the internet in regards to sexual crimes is dangerous. I understand the frustration of her and her family and I cannot say she was wrong to make the injustice public.

With that said, this is not a clear cut issue. I hope grace prevails and we do not attempt to ruin the boys lives in pursuit of vengeance. This is not something a mad internet does very well and would be a justifiable reason for the court to ban publication.

Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by tatsuke95 on Sunday July 22, 2012 @08:31AM (#4277202)
>"Naming people on the internet in regards to sexual crimes is dangerous."

Sexually assaulting people in real life is dangerous.

Why should the victim care one iota about what happens to these guys? Because of some arbitrary "moral-code", "justice" or "rule-of-law"? If this were me, I'd have done the same or worse. Which is why I can say, unabashedly, good for her. She witnessed first hand how the justice system works. They got their slap on the wrist, no she'll get hers.

Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by mikescar on Sunday July 22, 2012 @02:28AM (#4276629)
Two people pled guilty to sexual assault, in a public courtroom that we all fund to some degree.

You "hope grace prevails"? Are you trolling?

Grace for the victim, or the attackers? Whom, if they were a couple years older would have their names publicly available.

Again, we all fund this, there's no reason we shouldn't be able to get the information other than "it's not allowed now".

Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by Locke1689 on Sunday July 22, 2012 @04:44AM (#4276824)
Again, we all fund this, there's no reason we shouldn't be able to get the information other than "it's not allowed now".

This seems like a very strange and naïve way to look at government.

Think of government as the Rolling Stones: you can't always get what you want, but if you try sometimes, you might find you get what you need.

Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by mikescar on Sunday July 22, 2012 @09:55PM (#4279211)
What is your point, master philosopher?

Government accountability is a complete joke, but we should expect and demand better.

Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by SoftwareMaven on Sunday July 22, 2012 @01:45AM (#4276562)
So sexual assault is OK as long as they are kids? I have four kids and often think courts are ridiculously stupid for trying them as adults.

However, two of my kids are daughters. As the victim, their rights should trounce the rights of the attackers. That doesn't necessarily mean naming them, but if they aren't going to be named (which is usually the right thing to do for juveniles), they must be appropriately punished.

Unfortunately, we are missing whether they were appropriately punished. From her perspective, I'm sure the answer is No, but objectively, we don't know the answer.

I can't imagine how much it would suck to be a judge.

Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by lmm on Sunday July 22, 2012 @02:57AM (#4276663)
>So sexual assault is OK as long as they are kids?

OK? of course not. But it shouldn't destroy their whole lives, the way being publicly named would. As long as you're a kid you deserve another chance, even after murdering someone. That's the whole point of trying juveniles differently.

Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by lotharbot on Monday July 23, 2012 @03:37AM (#4279969)
We sometimes have a tendency to err on the side of whatever has the strongest emotional pull. It's important to protect your daughters from becoming victims, but don't forget that your sons can also be victimized by false accusations or even false convictions. Don't forget that what you think is "appropriate punishment" from hearing one side of the case may actually be far too much for the actual crime, or perhaps even a non-crime where someone plead guilty because the plea deal let them get on with their lives sooner and with less risk.

Criminals should be appropriately punished. But those decisions need to be made in light of all the facts, preferably within the legal system. Dumping the names out there on Twitter is, as an above post said, dangerous. Maybe these guys deserve it, but maybe "twitter justice" will give these guys -- or some innocent kid in a similar case -- punishment far beyond what they deserve.

Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by billswift on Sunday July 22, 2012 @12:01PM (#4277597)
>I can't imagine how much it would suck to be a judge.

Judges obviously don't think having gross amounts of almost completely unaccountable power sucks, or they wouldn't be judges.

Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by Locke1689 on Sunday July 22, 2012 @03:00AM (#4276669)
As the victim, their rights should trounce the rights of the attackers.

Why? Assuming we're still talking about rights as citizens under the law, here.

Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by heretohelp on Sunday July 22, 2012 @12:56AM (#4276496)
>Naming people on the internet in regards to sexual crimes is dangerous

Yes, it is! And this is what I want people talking about!

I don't have a particular point to make here, except to say that the discourse could be better.

Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by mikescar on Sunday July 22, 2012 @02:41AM (#4276641)
Victim's rights? More human policy-making? I wish.

Apparently not, guess the GP must be right and the victim got what was coming to her.

It's insane how detached we've become from the real world. Arguing about patents and iOS vs Android and open source. Two people pled guilty to a rape, within a court that we all pay for, and somehow there's a random smart-ass that wants to sound smart with the legal fatalism angle on this.

Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by overcyn on Sunday July 22, 2012 @12:39AM (#4276466)

    someone who has a different opinion than you
"annoying, obvious, contributes nothing"
Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by heretohelp on Sunday July 22, 2012 @12:45AM (#4276480)
It's annoying, obvious, and contributes nothing because:

1. Any state actions that promotes the current legal hegemony is inevitable, making a comment noting the fatalism inherent in taking an action (principled or not) that could trigger blowback from this legal hegemony is by definition obvious.

2. It's annoying because it doesn't say anything that isn't already evident from a passing understanding of the power dynamics of western society, especially as it relates to the courts. You don't need to say something emphasizing the power of the judicial system to ruin your life...we know that already.

3. And it contributes nothing because such comments rarely go beyond capitalizing on the opportunity to be snarky, doing nothing to describe the ethics of the situation or how the system could be improved.

Re:Kentucky teen faces charge for naming attackers in tweets by overcyn on Sunday July 22, 2012 @01:03AM (#4276502)
I guess I read his comment differently. "regardless of whether she's right or wrong" about the crimes/identities of the attacker.

Rather than regardless of whether she's in the right/wrong for posting their names.