News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Forgejo: A self-hosted lightweight software forge by geek_at on Sunday January 19, 2025 @11:42AM (#42758617)
> no premium upsells

So.. like gitea?

From my understanding the fork was done because gitea created a company to build custom-features for companies if they ask. Not really many indicators for a rugpull

Re:Forgejo: A self-hosted lightweight software forge by ffsm8 on Sunday January 19, 2025 @12:25PM (#42759118)
Fork timeline

    Gogs, inspired by GitHub - back when it still had the original old UI

    -> Gitea, forked with minor drama (claimed that they forking because the project wasn't maintained, which was untrue - they just didn't want to merge their PR)

     -> Gitea goes commercial, making previous community contributions into essentially free labor for their profit 
     ----> Forgejo forks Gitea (and never actually does anything new afaik, it's just Gitea under another name, while taking money too)

So, the original comment is spot on: the design is basically old GitHub, copied back in early 2010 by Gogs devs

Gitea did add several useful features over the years, which I think rationalized their pivot (vertical CI integration etc), but that's just my opinion as a Gogs user that doesn't need them.

Re:Forgejo: A self-hosted lightweight software forge by huijzer on Sunday January 19, 2025 @04:15PM (#42761925)
> (and never actually does anything new afaik, it's just Gitea under another name, while taking money too)

What evidence do you have for this strong claim? I’m using Forgejo and contributed to the docs once. It seems to me real work is happening in Forgejo. A lot from what I can see is stabilizing infrastructure and fixing bugs. Seems perfectly reasonable to me.

Re:Forgejo: A self-hosted lightweight software forge by Macha on Sunday January 19, 2025 @01:36PM (#42760027)
The money that Forgejo takes is €60/month in Liberapay donations, and some grants to develop federation features so I think it's a little disingenuous to compare it to Gitea's pivot to open core and hosted cloud service.
Re:Forgejo: A self-hosted lightweight software forge by mardifoufs on Sunday January 19, 2025 @02:45PM (#42760958)
How viable is gogs right now? I see that there is some activity on the repo but I guess there's no reason to not use Gitea or Forgejo?
Re:Forgejo: A self-hosted lightweight software forge by ffsm8 on Sunday January 19, 2025 @03:09PM (#42761254)
I actually went back to it after the gitea pivot and was surprised that it actually performed way better on my rpi.

But ymmv, I'm sure it's mostly because of how resource constrained it is.

It does what I want is completely FOSS and low maintenance. Perfect for my home setup, but different people will have different preferences

Re:Forgejo: A self-hosted lightweight software forge by yencabulator on Sunday January 19, 2025 @05:36PM (#42762772)
Plot twist: Gogs was never viable.

> In my point of view, as long as no deadlock..data race is unavoidable.

https://github.com/gogs/gogs/issues/613

> The payload comes from request somehow is not always in a clean format, so we have to preform a clean operation to remove unless characters:

    func cleanCommand(cmd string) string {
       i := strings.Index(cmd, "git")
       if i == -1 {
           return cmd
       }
       return cmd[i:]
    }
https://blog.gopheracademy.com/advent-2015/ssh-server-in-go/

https://github.com/gogs/gogs/issues/7777

Re:Forgejo: A self-hosted lightweight software forge by remram on Sunday January 19, 2025 @04:49PM (#42762260)
> Gitea goes commercial, making previous community contributions into essentially free labor for their profit

Gitea (like Gogs) is under MIT license, which allow commercial applications. Is the new expectation of open source that we grant everyone license terms that they shouldn't use? I don't understand this at all.

Forgejo is under GPL-3.0, which also allows commercial applications. Should we expect the Forgejo community to start name-calling any company that would use Forgejo according to its license terms?

Re:Forgejo: A self-hosted lightweight software forge by adduc on Sunday January 19, 2025 @06:54PM (#42763410)
There's a bit of a difference between a downstream commercial host and turning the open-source project into open-core. Gitea went from a rotating governance to deciding half of the decision-makers must now come from a for-profit company that now competes with the open-source offering.
Re:Forgejo: A self-hosted lightweight software forge by remram on Sunday January 19, 2025 @09:02PM (#42764224)
What's not in the "core"? More importantly, what is in Forgejo and not in Gitea's "core"?
Re:Forgejo: A self-hosted lightweight software forge by bramhaag on Sunday January 19, 2025 @05:03PM (#42762423)
> and never actually does anything new afaik, it's just Gitea under another name, while taking money too

This is really unfair to the many people who spend their free time working on Forgejo, please stop spreading nonsense. They have worked hard on "boring" improvements like translations, accessibility and proper unit and e2e testing, but also UI improvements, federation support, and other genuinely new features (asset quotas, wiki search, ...). Take a look for yourself: https://codeberg.org/forgejo/forgejo/pulls.

Regarding the money part, Forgejo is not monetized. It is a true FOSS project (recently re-licensed as GPLv3), not open-core like Gitea. The only funding they receive is from donations and grants, they are not selling a product.

Re:Forgejo: A self-hosted lightweight software forge by mort96 on Sunday January 19, 2025 @12:27PM (#42759148)
The pricing page (https://about.gitea.com/pricing/) talks about paywalled "Enhanced enterprise-level features and experiences". Are you sure that doesn't count as a premium upsell?