News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Programming Jargon by overcyn on Friday July 20, 2012 @08:06PM (#4273453)
Suppose you we're in charge of a q&a site whose quality was going downhill. How would you go about fixing it if not for locking and deleting questions?
Re:New Programming Jargon by dionidium on Friday July 20, 2012 @08:18PM (#4273478)
I don't think there's any evidence that these extremely popular, "fun" questions have any effect on the day-to-day programming queries submitted to StackOverflow. I haven't seen any presented.

Some people have an intuition that the presence of these historical bits contributes to a reduction in quality. I think that intuition is mistaken. Who knows who is right or even if that's a meaningful thing to ask. We're just discussing preferences.

Re:New Programming Jargon by mattgreenrocks on Friday July 20, 2012 @09:32PM (#4273638)
/r/programming should be enough of a cautionary note.

The mob is always happy to stoop to lower levels of discourse. It cannot be trusted to govern itself as a site grows. And most of the Internet is more than willing to cater to this out of fear of losing visitors. I say bravo. Let the 'gregarious' go elsewhere and live in the land of forum signatures, endless bike shedding, and editor wars once again.

Re:New Programming Jargon by 4ad on Saturday July 21, 2012 @04:02AM (#4274301)
Yeah, because edit wars are surely better than editor wars, and what we're doing now (with Jeff here!) is not bikeshedding.

The only questions on SO are the trivial questions that could be answered by reading some documentation. If questions are broad or open ended, the value lies in the discussion, not in any particular answer. I also found that many accepted answers are blatantly wrong. For me, SO has no value. /r/programming doesn't have any value either, but that doesn't make SO better.

Re:New Programming Jargon by mattgreenrocks on Saturday July 21, 2012 @07:53AM (#4274589)
SO wishes to remain a Q&A site, rather than a discussion site. They're intentionally limiting its scope. This is a very good thing.

There is a huge opportunity for a quality, ruthlessly moderated programming-centric discussion site. I'd argue that an aggregator is suboptimal over the long term due to the economic structure of the Internet favoring eyeballs over quality content.

I do agree that SO quality sucks at times, though.

Re:New Programming Jargon by tnorthcutt on Friday July 20, 2012 @11:08PM (#4273815)
FYI, I heartily agree, and accidentally fat-fingered the down arrow on my phone. Sorry about that.
Re:New Programming Jargon by overcyn on Saturday July 21, 2012 @03:04AM (#4274209)
So what would you do instead? Ignoring stack overflow (which I think is doing fine). How do you improve a community who's quality is declining? Do you just let it run its course for better or worse?

I really think moderation is the best choice.

Re:New Programming Jargon by bigiain on Friday July 20, 2012 @10:34PM (#4273766)
Personally, I think that unless you foster a community that'll self-police the quality, nothing else those "in charge" can do will help much in the long term.
Re:New Programming Jargon by Tangurena on Sunday July 22, 2012 @11:58AM (#4277592)
I deny the charge that it was "going downhill" before all the deletions started. If the "quality" is declining, then it is due to the vast quantities of new questions being asked, and the inability of regular users to find questions that they can answer.

Yogi Berra described the situation as "Nobody goes there anymore. Its too crowded".