News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Many Sides of Jack Dorsey by kragen on Friday July 20, 2012 @06:39PM (#4273205)
Like a raku tea bowl, or a haiku, or a Japanese rock garden? Those actually are Zen.
Re:The Many Sides of Jack Dorsey by Uchikoma on Saturday July 21, 2012 @12:39AM (#4273962)
No. A Haiku is not Zen. Haikus are influenced by Zen thinking or influenced by the same principles, but Haikus are not Zen. Rock gardens are not Zen. And tea bowls are not Zen.
Re:The Many Sides of Jack Dorsey by kragen on Saturday July 21, 2012 @07:41PM (#4276035)
Japanese rock gardens originate in Zen monastery practice in Kyoto. That is, Zen monks designed, built, and maintained them as part of their practice of Zen Buddhism. The best-known ones are all part of Zen Buddhist temples today. So in that sense, rock gardens are Zen.

The other two cases are not as open and shut.

Basho, who brought haiku into its modern form, was not a monk, but did practice Zen meditation as a layman, and lived as a pilgrim and hermit, teaching a circle of disciples, like an abbot. Issa, the second most influential haiku poet after Basho, was an honest-to-goodness Jodo Shinshu Buddhist (though not Zen!) priest. Furthermore, the haiku aesthetic embodies Zen's fierce focus on the ephemeral beauty of the current moment. I think that saying that the practice of haiku is "influenced by the same principles" is such an understatement as to be absurd.

Right now I am not going to dig into the history of raku.

Re:The Many Sides of Jack Dorsey by Uchikoma on Sunday July 22, 2012 @03:50AM (#4276734)
I didn't say Zen monks didn't build rock gardens or haikus are not influenced by Zen aesthetics and thinking. Equating rock gardens or haikus with Zen makes one laugh. Mu.

Zen is a school of buddhism which focuses on enlightenment, with different sub schools that focus on different methods for attaining enlightenment (well actually it's not, but it helps seeing Zen practitioners goal as gaining enlightment). Zen is not rock gardens, wabi sabi or haikus. Christianity is not building gothic cathedrals.

Glad I have no clue about Zen, or I would need to slap you on your head with a stick.

Re:The Many Sides of Jack Dorsey by kragen on Monday July 23, 2012 @12:28PM (#4281771)
Oh, I see where the disconnect was. You thought I was saying that the rock gardens were Zen Buddhism. I was saying that the rock gardens are Zen Buddhist, in the same way that the Gothic cathedrals are Christian or the Alhambra is Islamic.

Of course Zen does not consist of composing haiku, building rock gardens, or reading koans.