Most insightful comment in this thread. THIS is the crux of the issue, and we've allowed the likes of UHC to buy PBMs and other pieces of the supply chain / customer lifecycle because UHC lobbyists claim it would reduce costs across the board and also improve efficiency. Load of absolute bullshit obviously but here we are.
Is it the case that UnitedHealth and Cigna each own (or control) one of the "big three" PBMs? If so, that is a just crazy - the control insurance premium pricing, benefit decisions, AND the pricing of covered medications?
yadaebo wrote below "Medical Loss Ratio (MLR) is capped at 85% in the US which means 85% of revenue must go to patients". Does controlling a big PBM allow an insurance company a loophole?
>UHC is the largest single employer of doctors in the US.
https://www.statnews.com/2024/07/25/united-health-group-medi...
> It’s no secret that UnitedHealth is a colossus: It’s the country’s largest health insurer and the fourth-largest company of any type by revenue, just behind Apple. And thanks to a series of stealthy deals, almost 1 in 10 U.S. doctors — some 90,000 clinicians — now either work for UnitedHealth or are under its influence, more than any major clinic chain or hospital system.
>They purchase physician groups... and then pay themselves higher rates.
https://www.statnews.com/2024/11/25/unitedhealth-higher-paym...
> UnitedHealth Group is paying many of its own physician practices significantly more than it pays other doctor groups in the same markets for similar services, undermining competition and driving up costs for consumers and businesses, a STAT investigation reveals.
UnitedHealth Group is hardly unique in this regard. They're the largest but all the major commercial payers (including the non-profit ones) are pursuing similar strategies. Essentially they're copying the existing Kaiser-Permanente model of having a payer and provider organization under one roof.
I'm not defending this system, just explaining why the current structure exists. Any major improvements will require an Act of Congress to better align the incentives with the interests of patients / consumers / taxpayers.
…except you skipped over the part where UHC billed at higher rates for the clinics they own so they could screw customers with premium hikes, take a bigger percentage of of the inflated bills, as well as profit from whatever costs they didn’t cover and people were forced to pays.
There are no cost controls here. Just greed and malevolence all the way up and down the chain.
Isn't this clearly in need of trust bust?
At it's core, details are not really needed to show how atrociously inequitable the system is.
It’s worse in practice than any system adopted by any peer nation regardless of the wide range of differing approaches to providing universal coverage.
Treating it as some uniquely complicated problem is deceptive. It’s broken because that keeps certain people wealthy and gives employers control over labor.
> "Higher markups can also result in larger internal transfer payments from health plans to affiliated pharmacies, which may allow vertically integrated PBM-pharmacy-insurer entities to retain revenue and profits while formally satisfying the insurers' medical loss ratio ("MLR" ) requirements, but without providing the clinical care and quality improvements that the MLR rule seeks to promote. In addition, higher markups can result in significant patient cost sharing requirements because reimbursement rates are often correlated with point-of-sale prices, which can influence how much patients are required to pay."
In other words. Health insurance firms have capped profits in the US. But in this case one conglomerate can own both an insurer and a PBM, so it can just overcharge consumers for insurance and then launder its profits through the PBM.