News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Academic journals face a radical shake-up by jessriedel on Friday July 20, 2012 @09:39AM (#4270693)
> Here, manuscripts are subject to a ruthless process of open peer review, rather than the secret sort traditional publishers employ.

I don't know what this means. If the arXiv has some sort of open but centralized peer review, I haven't seen it. Maybe the economist just means that, once posted on the arXiv, a paper can be reviewed by anyone who wants and they can post on their blog. But this would be true of self-published papers, and no one would call that meaningful peer review.

> An arXived paper may end up in a traditional journal, but that is merely to provide an imprimatur for the research team who wrote it. Its actual publication, and its value to other scientists, dates from its original arrival online.

This isn't quite true. Depending on how lazy the journal referees are feeling, they can provide valuable feedback. Papers can change substantially during the review process (although this doesn't happen more often than it does). Typically, physicists update the arXiv version to reflect these changes.

There are no comments on this comment yet.