News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sonos CEO Patrick Spence steps down after disastrous app ... by lenerdenator on Monday January 13, 2025 @10:19AM (#42684331)
We don't really structure business law to allow for the appropriate amount of risk. The whole point of incorporation is to limit liability and shift what remains off of individuals at the company.

If you try to change this, you'll hear screeching about how there's just too much risk and the "job creators" will just take their capital and ideas to more business-friendly legal climes.

Re:Sonos CEO Patrick Spence steps down after disastrous app ... by michaelt on Monday January 13, 2025 @10:34AM (#42684539)
Eh, even keeping the mechanism of limited-liability-corporations around, some would say boards aren't representing shareholders' interests effectively.

It's one thing for shareholders to say if under the CEO's leadership, the company's value rises by 100 million dollars, they'll give him a $10 million bonus. I can see how a board could approve that - it's a lot of money, but it's linked to performance.

But should they also say that if the company's value falls by 100 million dollars, and they decide to fire the CEO, they'll give him a $2 million bonus? How is it in shareholders' interests to reward bad performance?

Re:Sonos CEO Patrick Spence steps down after disastrous app ... by tmoertel on Monday January 13, 2025 @11:29AM (#42685232)
One reason that CEOs get good severance packages is to entice them to leave other successful companies. If they are doing well at those other companies, are well liked by the board, and can reasonably expect to make a lot of money, why should they leave that safe, lucrative situation to come to your company, where there's a higher risk of failure or of falling out with the board? Enter the severance package. It guarantees the incoming execs a minimum payout that's large enough to entice them to give up what they'd expect to safely earn by staying where they are.
Re:Sonos CEO Patrick Spence steps down after disastrous app ... by michaelt on Monday January 13, 2025 @12:20PM (#42685864)
That's a great explanation for signing bonuses.

Doesn't do much to explain severance packages though?

Unless the board wants to give a signing bonus, but the amount is so egregious the shareholders would riot, so they need to do it by stealth.

Re:Sonos CEO Patrick Spence steps down after disastrous app ... by tmoertel on Monday January 13, 2025 @12:46PM (#42686203)
Yes, if you're an executive being lured away from your current position, both signing bonuses and severance packages will serve as insurance against your new position not working out. But, if you're on the board that's trying to lure an executive away, you should prefer severance packages to offer this insurance because you don't have to pay out until the relationship falls apart, and if you've chosen your new executive well, the relationship won't fall apart.
Re:Sonos CEO Patrick Spence steps down after disastrous app ... by pluc on Monday January 13, 2025 @12:45PM (#42686186)
Severance packages are usually negotiated from a position of power. You want me? Great, I'd like a 2M golden parachute.

If everyone they interview agrees to play the same game (and they do), it becomes a "necessity to attract top talent".

Re:Sonos CEO Patrick Spence steps down after disastrous app ... by nradov on Monday January 13, 2025 @01:53PM (#42687082)
Boards will sometimes write a severance package into a CEO's contract with an eye towards a possible future sale. When the company is acquired, the CEO will most likely lose their job. The Board thus wants to ensure that the CEO doesn't have a financial incentive to block a sale. A good severance package can increase shareholder value. (This is just a comment about severance packages in general, I have no idea what happened at Sonos.)
Re:Sonos CEO Patrick Spence steps down after disastrous app ... by nradov on Monday January 13, 2025 @01:54PM (#42687111)
What is the "appropriate amount of risk"? Please be specific. How do you quantify that? Should politicians decide that rather than shareholders, Board members, and management?
Re:Sonos CEO Patrick Spence steps down after disastrous app ... by lenerdenator on Monday January 13, 2025 @02:16PM (#42687448)
If I could answer that question to everyone's satisfaction, I'm not some rando on the internet.

But the justification for a lot of the incentives we give capital is "they shoulder all of the risk", and when your risk is walking away with a severance package that is often many multiples of the median lifetime earnings of the American male, you aren't really dealing with any real risk.