Re:Living with HTTPS
by peterwwillis on Thursday July 19, 2012 @02:59PM
(#4267532)
DNSSEC could allow this to work, if the connection between the client and a DNSSEC-enabled recursive resolver were secure. But if you're on the LAN of the client (for example, a wireless network) you can spoof every DNS response and the client is boned.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
... at the cost a myriad of other annoyances, breakages, and potential insecurities after DNSSEC is deployed. Deploying DNSSEC to help with the problem that HSTS is trying to solve is like deploying Homer Simpson's automatic hammer to pin an announcement to a bulletin board.
Re:Living with HTTPS
by peterwwillis on Thursday July 19, 2012 @05:04PM
(#4268059)
It's still one possible solution to the problem. If one's windows dns client were a DNSSEC-validating stub resolver[1], and you believe that in the future we will come to a point where network admins stop fucking with DNS traffic for no good reason, they could authenticate information from the website's dns on first-visit and avoid HSTS's pitfall. Note that I never said this was going to be practical :)
[1] https://www.internetsociety.org/deploy360/resources/dnssec-t...