Re:TikTok Says It Will 'Go Dark' Without US Court Intervention
by ASalazarMX on Sunday January 12, 2025 @02:45PM
(#42676269)
"I'm not taking your farm from you, I'm just forcing you to sell it to my friends, or close it."
An outright ban would be less circuitous.
Re:TikTok Says It Will 'Go Dark' Without US Court Intervention
by EA-3167 on Sunday January 12, 2025 @03:48PM
(#42676799)
An outright ban would be unconstitutional, and wouldn't be necessary. The issue is who owns and runs TikTok, so why not use legally extant powers to correct that? I'll add that this isn't a country versus a farmer, or even a country versus an individual... this is the US vs China.
So please, spare me the loaded analogy, there are no poor farmers here.
Re:TikTok Says It Will 'Go Dark' Without US Court Intervention
by ASalazarMX on Monday January 13, 2025 @01:49PM
(#42687045)
> The issue is who owns and runs TikTok, so why not use legally extant powers to correct that?
This is a step short of expropriation. If there are real security concerns, prove them and ban the product. It only matters who runs TikTok when you want control of it, not public security.
Weird that you focused of the word "farm", it could be easily taken as an online content farm.
Re:TikTok Says It Will 'Go Dark' Without US Court Intervention
by PittleyDunkin on Monday January 13, 2025 @09:30AM
(#42683746)
> But that's the thing, the US isn't banning TikTok, the US is forcing Bytedance to divest its majority control
To me this is indistinguishable from a ban, and I suspect the same is true for many of the politicians who actually voted for this. The semantic difference you bring up is irrelevant to most people.
The framing of this as a "ban" is truly one of the silliest aspects of this story, and allows the drawing of false equivalencies such as you've done above.