Re:Wrong Math
by seanhunter on Saturday January 11, 2025 @05:49AM
(#42664970)
Bet you’re fun at parties as they say.
I totally understand why simplifying assumptions are helpful in modelling and definitely don’t need you to explain that. It also is a bit ridiculous if you think literally about it which makes it something that is fun to laugh about as here.
Yes, sure, I get the jokes. I just found it puzzling that someone would think it stopped.
And I don’t talk about work at parties anyway :)
Re:Wrong Math
by eminent101 on Saturday January 11, 2025 @08:55AM
(#42665893)
But nobody in this thread thought it (simplifying assumptions) stopped. You seem to be making an assumption that someone thought that and then posting long explanations that nobody asked for. I read the "P.S." of grand-grand-parent comment as good humor. Nothing there implied that they really thought that simplifying assumptions would/should stop.
Imagine a world where every bit of humor is interpreted literally and then refuted pedantically! What kind of a world would that be?
Do you mean making simplifying assumptions to make a problem tractable? Of course it’s still going on. It has to be, otherwise you just cannot do anything.
> Assume the penguin's beak is a cone
It is impossible to consider the true shape of a penguin’s beak for several reasons:
- you’d need to go all the way down to the electron clouds of the atoms of the beak, at which point the very concept of shape is shaky
- every penguin has a different beak so even if you describe perfectly one of them, it does not necessarily make your calculation more realistic in general.
There is a spectrum of approximations one can make, but a cone is a sensible shape at a first order. It’s also simple enough that students can actually do it without years of experience and very advanced tools.
What do you think they should do instead?