News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by a5c11 on Friday January 10, 2025 @03:21AM (#42653734)
Does that mean they are going to push Europeans even harder, and do nothing to countries which are the real culprit?
Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by pjc50 on Friday January 10, 2025 @03:44AM (#42653841)
The real culprits are at the top of https://www.worldometers.info/co2-emissions/co2-emissions-pe... : gulf oil states, Australia, petrostate Canada, then the ones you'd expect like US and Russia.
Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by igg on Friday January 10, 2025 @04:34AM (#42654119)
This list seem to be based on production based accounting if emissions. Consumption-based per-capita emissions are available here for those curious: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/consumption-co2-per-capit...
Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by _aavaa_ on Friday January 10, 2025 @07:16AM (#42654968)
Is there a version of this that isn’t per capita? The environment cares about absolute amounts not per capita amounts.
Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by throawayonthe on Friday January 10, 2025 @07:26AM (#42655031)
absolute amounts of emissions by country is an arbitrary division, more people = more (demand for) industrial activity; for the numbers to be useful and actionable, they need to be understood in the context of the people those emissions are for, no?
Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by meany on Friday January 10, 2025 @10:39AM (#42656557)
Doesn’t that assume that the production isn’t for export. For instance, if the EU and US export their industries to low wage, high population countries you would see their per capita numbers drop and overall leveling out. However, the damage to the climate would be equal. Essentially, you need to look at a lot of factors and think holistically about the problem.
Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by _aavaa_ on Friday January 10, 2025 @11:19AM (#42656992)
No. The comment I replied to is about comsumption-based emissions, which attempt to account for exactly this. See the description in the link
Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by _aavaa_ on Friday January 10, 2025 @11:11AM (#42656917)
At the end of the day, it's one ecosystem we all live it. It doesn't matter if the top polluter has 1 billion, 0.1 billion, or 10 billion people. The total amount of greenhouses gasses added to the atmosphere is too much. We all need to stop adding and then start removing.

As for which metric to use, that depends on the argument you want to make. One can look at cumulative emissions and see how western nations have polluted much more historically, and should therefore do much more to clean up a mess their have contributed much more to.

Their governments will retort: "Oh but we produce so little of current global emissions now, those other countries polluting more should change first".

Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by Timon3 on Friday January 10, 2025 @01:05PM (#42658115)
But why are countries the best division? Why not continents, or unions of countries (e.g. EU or USA), or sub-country divisions like states, or even smaller regions? Countries don't have the highest possible impact on all people, that would probably be unions. It's also not the most direct impact, that would depend on each country, but for e.g. Germany that would be the individual states.

The per-capita measurement allows you to directly and meaningfully compare any subdivision, while per-country isn't even meaningfully comparable with other per-country measurements.

Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by _aavaa_ on Friday January 10, 2025 @02:29PM (#42659161)
> The per-capita measurement allows you to directly and meaningfully compare any subdivision, while per-country isn't even meaningfully comparable with other per-country measurements.

Compare to what end? The environment cares about total output, not per capita output.

> while per-country isn't even meaningfully comparable with other per-country measurements.

Why does it need to be?

Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by Timon3 on Friday January 10, 2025 @02:36PM (#42659248)
> Compare to what end? The environment cares about total output, not per capita output.

Yes, and the environment does not care in any way about countries or other silly subdivisions. So we approach the problem as each of us humans having some carbon budget based on the limits of our environment. You can argue how exactly these budgets are distributed, but it's the only measure that matters. Because again: you're arbitrarily choosing to look at countries, when even other subdivisions along the same axis would make more sense. So why focus on countries specifically?

> Why does it need to be?

Because obviously a measurement that's comparable is more useful than one that isn't. It allows us to make determinations about what changes bring us closer to the goal of environmental sustainability, and which changes bring us further away. Do I really need to go on further?

Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by _aavaa_ on Friday January 10, 2025 @04:23PM (#42660395)
> So why focus on countries specifically?

Because it is at the country level that people corporate on international problems. And in many countries it is the federal (or equivalent level) which has the money required to build out the kind of projects needed change those numbers (or the legal authority to mandate it).

Ahh. I misunderstood what you meant. > while per-country isn't even meaningfully comparable with other per-country measurements.

I interpreted as “other per-country measurements” as (other measurements) not (same metric, different country).

I still think it’s not relevant. The changes and the target are still the same, i.e. stop burning shit.

Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by Timon3 on Friday January 10, 2025 @04:50PM (#42660677)
> Because it is at the country level that people corporate on international problems.

It's also at the union level that people corporate on international problems, arguably more so than on the country level. Yet the largest differences occur at the regional level. Both would be more comparable, and would capture arguably more useful information. I just don't see how an arbitrary and incomparable measurement is better than one without those flaws.

> I still think it’s not relevant. The changes and the target are still the same, i.e. stop burning shit.

Yes, but it's easier to implement the necessary changes if everyone tries. It will be much harder to get the necessary investment from all voting populations if large discrepancies exist between groups of people.

Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by _aavaa_ on Friday January 10, 2025 @08:06PM (#42662316)
I think we’re talking about different things now. I’m saying that emissions should be measured one absolute levels per country since a) absolute pollution is what matters and) countries are the political blocks that dictate international laws and cooperations.

You seem to be talking about the groupings by unions and regions. I am unconvinced that people have a stronger affiliation for those than their country. Further, measuring emissions levels for the country as a whole. On a practical level, getting emission levels for a specific region or a specific union, must less particular individuals, is going to be much harder.

Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by Timon3 on Saturday January 11, 2025 @04:31AM (#42664585)
> I am unconvinced that people have a stronger affiliation for those than their country.

Why is the affiliation the relevant axis? Why not indirect political power (unions strongest) or direct political power (regions strongest)? You're arbitrarily choosing an arbitrary measurement.

> Further, measuring emissions levels for the country as a whole. On a practical level, getting emission levels for a specific region or a specific union, must less particular individuals, is going to be much harder.

I don't see how it could be more complex for unions since they are made up of countries. If we have measurements for countries, we have measurements for unions.

Similarly, you can't create country-wide measurements without measuring individual regions. At least in Germany we have pretty good coverage for the individual regions, which gives you much higher resolution data. So why not use that?

I don't see how you can arrive at "countries" as the best/most logical axis of measurement. The only use I see is if you want to tell people that other countries have much further to go (but I'm not accusing you of doing so).

Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by pjc50 on Friday January 10, 2025 @02:26PM (#42659106)
> It doesn't matter if the top polluter has 1 billion, 0.1 billion, or 10 billion people

Each polluter is an individual person making individual decisions.

The thing people are dancing around is any concept of "rationing", because that's political suicide, but at the same time asking people who've only just got clean water and walk to work to reduce emissions while other people are taking multiple transatlantic flights per week looks a bit questionable.

Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by _aavaa_ on Friday January 10, 2025 @04:25PM (#42660419)
> The thing people are dancing around is any concept of "rationing"

I don’t know who those people are. Also, another way to say rationing is “sharing”.

Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by comte7092 on Friday January 10, 2025 @11:18AM (#42656986)
While your statement is fundamentally correct, the issue here is that people typically use these charts as an excuse to point the finger.

The tension globally is between the west who has high per capita emissions, a long period of high emissions, and high living standards as compared to the global south who have a larger population and lower living standards and yet still high absolute levels of emissions.

Telling China/india/et al that they’re the real problem is taken as “yeah we polluted for centuries to get rich but that’s all in the past, you need to stay poor in order to save the planet”.

An alternative solution might be to have the west pay to help these countries develop more sustainably, but that’s met with anger by the rising nationalist elements. I mean even importing green tech from the global leader (China) is being resisted.

Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by lm28469 on Friday January 10, 2025 @03:28AM (#42653764)
Which countries?
Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by matthewmacleod on Friday January 10, 2025 @04:52AM (#42654216)
Who is “they”?
Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by acadapter on Friday January 10, 2025 @08:12AM (#42655316)
I assume the unspecific "they" is a linguistic shortcut for "people in power"
Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by toomuchtodo on Friday January 10, 2025 @09:24AM (#42655785)
China is rapidly decarbonizing, India is right behind, it is the US you have to convince to move faster (coal plants are rapidly on their way out, but US consumers prefer ICE pickups over EVs, and LNG exports must be prevented and substitutes found [carbon footprint determined to be substantially higher than coal]). Europeans have, for the most part, done very well considering the carbon profile of everything west of Poland. But they also need to speed up the EV uptake, with domestic EU automakers pleading "it's too hard" while China eats their lunch. Norway shows they way here imho, as they have reached their 2025 deadline of only new EVs being sold. Battery manufacturing is needed, as much as possible, batteries are the future of anything not seasonal storage.

We did not leave the stone age because we ran out of stone, but because we found something better. This applies to renewables, EVs, batteries, etc as well, the problem is mostly solved, it is a matter of making the machine go faster is all. We need enough low carbon energy to replace everything fossil today (account for the orders of magnitude efficiency gains versus thermal generation, so not a 1:1 replacement needed), future energy growth, and energy needed to sequester 100+ years of emitted carbon.

The exponential growth of solar power will change the world - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40746617 - June 2024

(the Earth collects enough solar radiation in less than an hour to power humanity for a year)

Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by KptMarchewa on Friday January 10, 2025 @10:50AM (#42656673)
> China is rapidly decarbonizing, India is right behind, it is the US you have to convince to move faster (coal plants are rapidly on their way out, but US consumers prefer ICE pickups over EVs, and LNG exports must be prevented and substitutes found [carbon footprint determined to be substantially higher than coal]).

IDK, does not look that way:

https://climateactiontracker.org/countries/china/ https://climateactiontracker.org/countries/india/ https://climateactiontracker.org/countries/usa/ https://climateactiontracker.org/countries/eu/

At best China will stay the same, India will increase emissions, meanwhile both US and EU emissions will significantly drop.

Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by toomuchtodo on Friday January 10, 2025 @11:54AM (#42657371)
I argue this ignores rate of change of manufacturing capacity and deployment trajectories, but concede all we can do is speculate based on data available today.
Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by GenerWork on Friday January 10, 2025 @12:34PM (#42657788)
>it is the US you have to convince to move faster...LNG exports must be prevented and substitutes found

>Europeans have, for the most part, done very well

These exports are happening because Europe has replaced its Russian gas with American gas.

Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by toomuchtodo on Friday January 10, 2025 @12:36PM (#42657800)
I am aware. Relying on gas imports of any sort is unsustainable long term (both from a geopolitical and environmental perspective), although they are a necessary bridge until EU energy security is reached.
Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by toomuchtodo on Saturday January 11, 2025 @08:46PM (#42670514)
Europe Moves Further Away From Russian Gas -https://www.northerntrust.com/united-states/insights-researc... - Jan 2025
Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by t0bia_s on Saturday January 11, 2025 @03:57AM (#42664439)
Not sure if true, bit if so... You think it's less environment invasive to import gas from far away USA on tankers than bring it by pipes from country near by?
Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by hn1986 on Friday January 10, 2025 @03:18PM (#42659658)
Won't make a difference if the leaders (Trump) doing even believe in climate change.
Re:2024 first year to pass 1.5C global warming limit by whamlastxmas on Friday January 10, 2025 @03:23PM (#42659706)
Trump believes in it despite some past assertions around the narrative around climate change being silly, which to be fair, can be at times. He does dismiss it too much though and clearly promotes corporate greed and profit for others over environmental issues