Hydrogen is dangerous and difficult to store, dangerous and difficult to transport, and has egregious specific energy density--all of them are deal-killers for any widespread fuel.
The only two benefits of hydrogen over other fuels are:
1. The cleanest and most efficient combustion 2. Ease of synthesis on a distributed scale
Ammonia beats hydrogen on every front aside from:
1. Less efficient/clean combustion (which we can handle with extant NoX scrubbing technologies) 2. Currently, it's only efficient to manufacture it in large-scale non-distributed industrial plants.
The great thing about ammonia is we've been manufacturing and storing it at-scale for about a century so we're really good at it. Ammonia is the best current candidate for replacing bunker oil and diesel in shipping.
In fact, fun fact, it makes for an incredibly good dilutant for extremely deep scuba diving (you can't breathe pure oxygen underwater and most gases, including oxygen, become toxic under pressure). For some reason though, people are queasy about the idea of mixing pure hydrogen and oxygen hundreds of meters underwater.
There's been quite a few deaths from industrial ammonia tank (plant, truck, railcar), leaks but unlike hydrogen there's zero chance for a combustion explosion or incidental damage from fire.
Ammonia also almost immediately diffuses and dissipates in air at atmospheric conditions, so while it's VERY toxic it's only VERY toxic for a VERY brief period of time (a few minutes).
One of the odd "safety" benefits with ammonia is that it takes a rather special set of circumstances for it to combust in the first place. That makes it a sub-optimal fuel in many applications--notably aviation.
Thanks for that neat fact about using hydrogen in diving. I'm only familiar with trimixes or bimixes of oxygen, nitrogen, and helium.
Interesting read re breathing hydrogen: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydreliox
It's also extremely noxious at even very low (safe) concentrations so, unlike odorless methane, hydrogen, or carbon monoxide, people know immediately to stay away from the area.
The natural gas (mostly methane) that's piped into housing for heating or cooking is deliberately ordorized with hydrogen sulfide to make it noxious so gas leaks can be smelled.
Because it's far cheaper than diesel or hydrogen.
60% of the cost of trucking is fuel. A reduction in that provides a massive competitive advantage that will push out other trucks. Trucking is a highly competitive low margin business.
Green hydrogen uses about 3X the electricity per mile as a battery powered truck, it can never be competitive on cost. It may be better in every other way, but cost is primary.
Personally, I think they could have done some quick cocktail napkin math and figured out their strategy without too much effort, but large mega corps tend to frown upon that sort of thing. I remember the Honda clarity (a retro-fitted civic) was going for $350K and saying to myself: no one thought to use a spreadsheet before building?