You need to take into account that your interaction with a book is usually short while the effects of your interactions with people accumulate over time.
It might be different for people with very strong personality but I think it is generally true that we are strongly affected by the people we surround ourselves with.
The theory breaks down when you don't spend time with anyone, because you can't divide by zero!
A live human being is no more influential to me than a good book. If you really want to get a good "5" and you can't find enough talented people, consider replacing your unwanted friends with dead trees.