News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Cracked a 512-Bit DKIM Key for Less Than $8 in the Cloud by unwind on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @08:18AM (#42633881)
So 1,700 out of 1,000,000, i.e. around 0.2%. "Not common" is one way of putting it, I guess.
Re:We Cracked a 512-Bit DKIM Key for Less Than $8 in the Cloud by awulf on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @09:02AM (#42634298)
I agree, but to be precise, it was 1,726 out of 476,617 DKIM keys found across those 1M domains, or about 0.36%. Since it's impossible to determine all DKIM records a domain might have from the outside, I used a list of commonly used selectors (e.g., "default' or 'key1") for the search. It's likely there are additional short keys under selectors I didn't check.
Re:We Cracked a 512-Bit DKIM Key for Less Than $8 in the Cloud by croemer on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @08:25AM (#42633938)
Those 1,700 are easy to find though, just need to dig a bunch of domain names and you'll find plenty vulnerable ones that you can spoof.

Yahoo Mail has a market share on the order of 3%. So a black hat could then target a decent chunk of users with @yahoo addresses specifically.

Has anyone heard of this being exploited in the wild? Would be interesting to find out whether there are some reputable domains among the 1.7k vulnerable ones.

Re:We Cracked a 512-Bit DKIM Key for Less Than $8 in the Cloud by elif on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @08:31AM (#42633993)
Your claim that yahoo uses a 512bit key are counterfactual.

Please adhere to honesty and good faith arguments.

Re:We Cracked a 512-Bit DKIM Key for Less Than $8 in the Cloud by croemer on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @08:38AM (#42634068)
I never suggested that Yahoo uses 512bit keys, that's a misunderstanding.

The article clearly states that Yahoo is one of the 3 clients that didn't reject 512bit keys the way they should per RFC.

Yahoo Mail inbox users are vulnerable _receivers_ of spoofed emails.

Re:We Cracked a 512-Bit DKIM Key for Less Than $8 in the Cloud by 1oooqooq on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @10:59AM (#42635523)
remember when yahoo mail was the first one to implement DKIM validation and then all mailing list owners added a footer telling their subscribers not to use yahoo mail because it was broken, instead of calling their mailing list providers to upload a key? yeah nobody remembers, but yahoo probably do. i doubt they will err on the side of security again.
Re:We Cracked a 512-Bit DKIM Key for Less Than $8 in the Cloud by jaza on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @05:30PM (#42639194)
The Yahoo that built Yahoo Mail no longer exists, so actually they probably don't remember.
Re:We Cracked a 512-Bit DKIM Key for Less Than $8 in the Cloud by philipwhiuk on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @09:24AM (#42634556)
The top million domains are more likely to be on top of their security than less prominent domains. 0.2% is therefore a fairly strict lower bound for the overall internet.