His proposed architecture wasn't without elegance, but it was also more complex and, more importantly, it didn't solve any problems that we actually had. So in the end it was more of an ideological thing.
He seemed to take it personally that we didn't take him up on his proposal, and he left a few months later (and went back to his previous employer, though to a different group). Don't think he was around for even a year. He wasn't young either; he was pretty experienced.
This would mean that when rolling out a new version, usually only the shared library would need to be replaced. So.. significantly more complexity, due to now having a more arms-length interface between the executable and the business logic in the shared libraries. And the payoff was.. when deploying, we would upgrade a shared library instead of an executable? Still doesn't seem worthwhile.
Indeed, the developer was one of the best programmers I've known and absolutely the key person on the system. The New Guys Clique were the sort of developers, you might know some, who come in, look at the existing systems, decide it's all wrong and terrible, and set out to Do It Right.