News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EFF Challenges National Security Letter Statute in Landma... by jkn on Wednesday July 18, 2012 @04:05PM (#4262645)
I've been wondering why humorous comments are so rare on HN, and this one just got downvoted. Is there a rule that comments should be serious?

Anyway this was at least half serious so not a good example I suppose.

Re:EFF Challenges National Security Letter Statute in Landma... by samdk on Wednesday July 18, 2012 @04:28PM (#4262758)
I think that many people post jokes here because on other similar sites they're an easy way to get (often quite a lot of) upvotes, and a lot of us here dislike that mentality.

My criteria for upvoting a joke are generally the same as my criteria for upvoting any other comment: if I feel it adds something to the discussion, it gets an upvote. If I feel like it contributes nothing at all, it gets a downvote, because reading it is a waste of someone's time.

Most of the jokes posted here are surface humor. They are relatively obvious and add nothing to the discussion, and so I downvote quite a lot of them.

Occasionally someone will use humor to make a good point, and then I will upvote them. In general I'd discourage it, though--it's usually much easier and clearer to just say what you mean, and people here are usually receptive to well-argued points.

Re:EFF Challenges National Security Letter Statute in Landma... by lmm on Thursday July 19, 2012 @05:37AM (#4265219)
There's a post from pg that I wish I could find where he says something along the lines of "the greatest enemy of intelligent discussion is not the outright troll but the witty one-liner". There's no rule against humour that I know of, but there is a culture that believes it's often detrimental to the discussion.
Re:EFF Challenges National Security Letter Statute in Landma... by davidw on Thursday July 19, 2012 @09:03AM (#4265757)
Because it's not funny - it's just a silly, hyperbolic meme.

I've had funny comments upvoted (and a few I thought were funny downvoted, but c'est la vie).

( I always liked this one: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=458155 )