News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Engineer eats efficiently for $2.50 a day (2016) by detourdog on Monday January 06, 2025 @07:37AM (#42610065)
One can have whey without the calf dying. I have personally seen whey produced without harming calves.

I also don't understand why some HNer's insist on downvoting simple questions. Trying to silence questioning is not healthy for society.

Re:Engineer eats efficiently for $2.50 a day (2016) by aziaziazi on Monday January 06, 2025 @08:40AM (#42610468)
I agree with the downvote think.

What you have seen (whey without calves harm) is probably typical an old farming practice OR of some rural family production. That’s great for them and their cows, but have nothing to do with 99% of the milk consumed daily, even the best quality you can buy wherever else those farms are.

Re:Engineer eats efficiently for $2.50 a day (2016) by detourdog on Monday January 06, 2025 @11:45AM (#42612172)
Do you think all dairy cows need calves to create milk? I don't care if someone disagrees with my posts I agree that they engage in conversation. Downvoting without explanation is my complaint. Finally the comment that whey production results in dead calves is pretty simplistic and not based on any analysis that I can discern.

If HN is about the struggle for truth I expect a certain amount of intellectual rigor in comments.

Re:Engineer eats efficiently for $2.50 a day (2016) by aziaziazi on Monday January 06, 2025 @04:41PM (#42616228)
I meant "I agree with you about the downvote think".

I also read your explanation in sibling thread. IMHO you’re right about the calves not-killed if we only look for a specific time frame , but it can’t work on the long run. If you can please share some materials for us to learn more. Also, cows definitely needs a clave to start the milk production.

Re:Engineer eats efficiently for $2.50 a day (2016) by GrantMoyer on Monday January 06, 2025 @09:40AM (#42610907)
So what did they do with the calf?
Re:Engineer eats efficiently for $2.50 a day (2016) by detourdog on Monday January 06, 2025 @11:39AM (#42612082)
Wait until it is done weaning to start using it's mother's milk. Most Dairy cows don't need to have a calf to produce milk.
Re:Engineer eats efficiently for $2.50 a day (2016) by GrantMoyer on Monday January 06, 2025 @02:36PM (#42614585)
> Wait until it is done weaning to start using it's mother's milk.

Then what happens to the calf? They raise it to the end of it's natural lifespan as a pet? Are male and female calves treated differently?

> Most Dairy cows don't need to have a calf to produce milk.

I can't find anything to corroborate this. Every source I find on the topic says dairy cows produce milk for up to about one year after giving birth, then they need to be re-impregnated to begin producing milk again. Do you have a source for this claim?

Re:Engineer eats efficiently for $2.50 a day (2016) by svieira on Monday January 06, 2025 @12:47PM (#42612931)
The mother very quickly starts producing more milk than the calf can drink. In the wild the milk production levels off to the level of the calf's intake (and then slowly rises to match their needs as they age and then tapers off as they age further).

In a small dairy situation the calves are kept off of the cows for either the morning or the evening milking and so the cows' milk production remains high the entire time. The calf weans, but from the cow's udder's perspective the calf is still suckling like mad and so the cow keeps producing milk. The calf grows up and is bred themselves, doubling the milk output over the course of two to three years.

Now this isn't sustainable in a paperclip-optimizer kind of way, so only the best milkers are kept and the ones that either have a hard time getting pregnant, or are ornery, or produce less milk, or get sick regularly wind up getting harvested for their meat. But there's no need to kill the calves (at the local dairy scale).

Re:Engineer eats efficiently for $2.50 a day (2016) by GrantMoyer on Monday January 06, 2025 @02:31PM (#42614522)
What about male calves?
Re:Engineer eats efficiently for $2.50 a day (2016) by svieira on Monday January 06, 2025 @11:38PM (#42619296)
Raise them up to a steer if you don't need breeding stock and use / sell them as a bull if you do.
Re:Engineer eats efficiently for $2.50 a day (2016) by GrantMoyer on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @08:43AM (#42622195)
Okay, so most of calves are still killed, but maybe after they grow up rather than while they're calves?
Re:Engineer eats efficiently for $2.50 a day (2016) by aziaziazi on Monday January 06, 2025 @04:32PM (#42616131)
I still don’t understand how you keep the calves alive. Ok for one or two year but if you want to maintain a regular production over the years, at some point you’ll have a bunch of male cows (not sure the right English word for that) and a bunch of "bad milker cows". I mean I totally agree what you describe is possible and even the reality in a few ranch but it has nothing to do with what’s happening for the vast majority of cows.

Side note: on the other side of the calves killing scale, some farmers (in Swissland at least) started to kill male calves directly at birth because they found it more profitable at scale. Yummy Toblerone!