News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Advice for Marissa Mayer from an ex-Yahoo by grannyg00se on Wednesday July 18, 2012 @12:10AM (#4259302)
What the hell? You're comparing a Blackberry to something that hasn't been in production for what...decades? Blackberry 9900 came out fairly recently and has a pretty damn good browser experience. I'm not sure why there's so much anti Blackberry sentiment here.

I agree that that it probably shouldn't be official policy to have Blackberries for employees, but if you're going to allow Android and iPhone, you might as well allow Blackberry for those who still want to keep it. It's not like we're talking about an IE6 type of burden here. The BB9900 browser is not crusty at all.

Re:Advice for Marissa Mayer from an ex-Yahoo by mratzloff on Wednesday July 18, 2012 @11:00AM (#4261029)
It's about dogfooding your product. Yahoo has traditionally had terrible results with its mobile products. Well, here's one reason why.
Re:Advice for Marissa Mayer from an ex-Yahoo by mikeash on Wednesday July 18, 2012 @09:49AM (#4260676)
I was using hyperbole to illustrate how a piece of equipment that's good at its nominal job could still be a disastrous choice.

You say the BB9900 has a good browser experience. Pulling it up, I see the typical BB form factor with a half-sized screen and a keyboard. I don't care how objectively good that is, it doesn't match what Yahoo's users are using.

Beyond the browsing experience, apps are becoming more important all the time, and approximately nobody is building BB apps. Anybody at Yahoo using a BB phone, no matter how good or how recent, will get a deeply skewed view of what their users actually experience and expect.