Re:
by sneak on Friday January 03, 2025 @07:29PM
(#42590999)
Hijacking deprives someone else of their rights. Living differently than your neighbor doesn’t change anything for your neighbor. Nothing is “hijacked”.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:
by yhg56fgniyfv on Friday January 03, 2025 @07:39PM
(#42591061)
If all your neighbors no longer spoke English, you don't think that would affect you?
Obviously that's an extreme example, but other cultural differences will affect you as well.
Re:
by BobaFloutist on Friday January 03, 2025 @09:08PM
(#42591647)
If they all spoke a common language, I'd try to learn a bit of it. How exciting!
It's also exciting to experience ethnic clashes between rival groups of immigrants[1].
[1] https://toronto.citynews.ca/2024/11/03/violence-at-hindu-tem...
"Wow all these Goths have moved into my town, but they don't speak Latin, they speak Gothic. How exiting!"
- Anonymous Roman Citizen, 412 AD
It can be a really cool thing too if both cultures open each other to exchange languages and celebrations, but it requires a lot of effort from everyone.
No, I don’t. This is already the case in many neighborhoods in the USA and the sky isn’t falling in those places.
Also, I live in Germany half of the year, and there most of my neighbors don’t speak any English, and my neighborhood is fine. I don’t see the problem you are describing with your example.
If that’s your “extreme” example, I am curious what your day-to-day ones would be.
Perhaps it’s uncharitable but I am having a hard time seeing how this doesn’t alias to simple racism.
Re:
by yhg56fgniyfv on Saturday January 04, 2025 @04:13PM
(#42597719)
I didn't claim the "sky would fall". I just claimed it would affect you.
I think most would agree that it is easier to form connections with those who are more similar to oneself. Call it racism or tribalism if you want, but that's reality.
I think it hijacks the local culture, there's probably a better word, but I'm no native.
It's mind boggling you are denying the fact that having many people from the same group clustered in a "multicultural" environment has no impact on society has a whole. Of course it does, this is why we have laws protecting minorities, it's irrelevant how the majority is established (either per-existing or minority suddenly growing), the impact may be positive but it's naive to assume it will always be so.