News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Morgan Stanley Follows Citi, BofA in Quitting Climate Group by moominpapa on Thursday January 02, 2025 @02:44PM (#42577986)
What percentage of the Earth's atmosphere is CO2? It's 0.04% in case you didn't know. Why would anyone who didn't know the answer to that question be so sure that CO2 is causing climate change? I know someone who has a very lucrative job working as a climate change advisor or somesuch and possibly believes they are doing noble work whilst they live an indulgent life off the proceeds of their rented out properties. I suspect a middle class scam.
Re:Morgan Stanley Follows Citi, BofA in Quitting Climate Group by tkluck on Thursday January 02, 2025 @03:18PM (#42578366)
Are you making the claim that small numbers are always irrelevant? In that case it's worth reading up on the greenhouse effect. It's unfortunately very true that water vapour and CO2 have an outsize effect on the planet's heat balance.

You mix that claim with an implication about people who don't know that number off the top of their heads, but: - work on sustainability for feelgood - are independently wealthy otherwise.

I don't understand exactly what you're implying but it doesn't seem very generalizable. Society can face arbitrarily complicated threats, to counter which we can create incentives even for those who don't know the details.

How to get political agreement on the important threats and the best (effective / fair / ...) incentives is an open problem.

Re:Morgan Stanley Follows Citi, BofA in Quitting Climate Group by moominpapa on Thursday January 02, 2025 @03:30PM (#42578508)
That wasn't my point entirely but admittedly it was a part of it. I have not heard a good reason for why a trace gas has such an effect. Bearing in mind that 0.04% is total CO2 and human produced CO2 is a tiny fraction of that - can't seem to find an agreed on percentage on that one but happy to be enlightened. The other point I was making is that when I have asked that basic question to people who are seemingly frightened of the effects of CO2 I have got massively inflated guesstimates e.g. 50%. I just think if you are going to be scared and try and scare others you should know at least that.
Re:Morgan Stanley Follows Citi, BofA in Quitting Climate Group by tkluck on Thursday January 02, 2025 @03:57PM (#42578809)
Gotcha, I see. You're not wrong that a combination of scientific illiteracy and political orthodoxy can give terrible outcomes. So some default skepticism is quite wise.

If you want to understand the effect of the trace gases from first principles, you can read more about it under "Effective temperature of the Earth" at https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stefan%E2%80%93Boltzmann_law . It also links to the Wikipedia page about the greenhouse effect, which you'll appreciate more after reading about the Stefan Boltzmann law first.

Re:Morgan Stanley Follows Citi, BofA in Quitting Climate Group by moominpapa on Thursday January 02, 2025 @04:14PM (#42578995)
OK, will read, much appreciated. Just have to deal with my fence that blew down in the high winds we had in the UK yesterday - climate change no doubt (joke). Thank you.
Re:Morgan Stanley Follows Citi, BofA in Quitting Climate Group by netsharc on Thursday January 02, 2025 @02:51PM (#42578074)
You seem to be implying that this percentage is very low, so how could it be responsible for climate change?

You seem to be doing the opposite of your question, knowing the answer to the question and then concluding (without knowledge of how the whole system works) that since it's so low that it couldn't be responsible for drastic changes.

Re:Morgan Stanley Follows Citi, BofA in Quitting Climate Group by moominpapa on Thursday January 02, 2025 @03:35PM (#42578557)
Yes, the implication is there and I am happy to be shown why CO2 is so key when man-made contributions to that tiny amount is so small also
Re:Morgan Stanley Follows Citi, BofA in Quitting Climate Group by netsharc on Thursday January 02, 2025 @04:13PM (#42578989)
Aha... I like the confidence that "I'm right, all those climate scientists are swindlers", based on your knowledge that "0.04% is a very small number". True, you probably would not lose sleep after e.g. losing 0.04% of your investments, but I dare say, believing this translates to the area of climate change is an act of supreme ignorance.

As for the rest of your stance, I asked ChatGPT: https://chatgpt.com/share/6776fe8b-8bd0-800e-875f-bae617ccfd...

Re:Morgan Stanley Follows Citi, BofA in Quitting Climate Group by moominpapa on Thursday January 02, 2025 @04:29PM (#42579143)
You appear to have created a straw man. Your prompt assumes I am a climate change denier, when it might have been better to have labelled me a man-made climate change skeptic. Not sure chatGPT is the way to go on this one as I'd imagine it will be weighted towards the consensus. There was once a consensus that the Earth was the centre of the Universe. Anyway thanks for the link, I enjoyed it.
Re:Morgan Stanley Follows Citi, BofA in Quitting Climate Group by netsharc on Friday January 03, 2025 @04:44AM (#42584180)
> Your prompt assumes I am a climate change denier, when it might have been better to have labelled me a man-made climate change skeptic

Duck me, as if that hair-splitting makes a huge difference. I dare say there's a 0.04% difference between the two.

You flaunt your superficial intellect but you're still ignorant as hell, using it to nitpick. Did you figure out the Stefan-Boltzmann law? Or is it yet again somebody's job to convince you? Oh noo the wind blew your fence down so you were denied the chance to be proven wrong, therefore you're still this smart and correct man? Whatever saves your ego, man.

Re:Morgan Stanley Follows Citi, BofA in Quitting Climate Group by moominpapa on Friday January 03, 2025 @07:12AM (#42584967)
If you think there is little difference between someone who does not believe the climate is changing and someone who can well believe it is (that's what the climate does), but isn't entirely convinced it's man-made there's not much I can do about that. Funnily enough AI returned the following on the Stefan-Boltzmann law: The Stefan-Boltzmann law is a fundamental physical law that helps explain Earth's energy balance, but it doesn't account for the greenhouse effect, which is a key part of the climate system Anyway, I was pleased to have this pointer, and intend to look more thoroughly in to this life/fence permitting. BTW, I do not think ad hominim attacks are the way to bring someone over to your way of thinking. Cheers.
Re:Morgan Stanley Follows Citi, BofA in Quitting Climate Group by netsharc on Friday January 03, 2025 @03:30PM (#42589195)
Yeah, it's hard to get anyone who smugly think they know it all to realize that they're actually an idiot. I don't care about changing your viewpoint, for all I care, you stay you, so anyone who can see through that thin veneer can see they should stay away from a fool.

For future reference, it's spelled "ad hominem".

Re:Morgan Stanley Follows Citi, BofA in Quitting Climate Group by moominpapa on Friday January 03, 2025 @05:30PM (#42590155)
> I don't care about changing your viewpoint, for all I care, you stay you, so anyone who can see through that thin veneer can see they should stay away from a fool.

And yet you keep coming back with nothing but ad hominem (cheers spellcheck guy). Right, I'm gonna leave it there; it's been emotional. All the best.