Re:Google+ grows 43% in June
by jedberg on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @03:28PM
(#4257398)
Seconded. Compete's numbers are just made up. I know for sure they are off by more than an order of magnitude for reddit (or at least were a year ago).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Google+ grows 43% in June
by Josh2600hz on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @03:31PM
(#4257418)
Most of the traffic tracking on the web involves plugins (generally in the form of a toolbar). I don't know about you guys, but I haven't had a 3rd party toolbar in my browser interface in a long time.
Compete, Alexa, etc. they're all tracking people who don't understand technology.
But it IS fair to say that the demographics of the set of users who have toolbars installed into their browser is different than those who do not.
Specifically, those that have them installed are more likely to be non-tech users than those without.
That's my guess with 0 data to back it up (but plenty of useless anecdotes!)
Re:Google+ grows 43% in June
by jcampbell1 on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @04:24PM
(#4257676)
Compete buys samples of traffic from ISPs as its primary datasource. Your toolbar theory is incorrect.
> Compete, Alexa, etc. they're all tracking people who don't understand technology.
That would mean that G+ is even stronger as it seems mainly popular with the tech crowd.
I generally agree with your sentiment, but let's not get carried away: using 3rd party toolbars does not automatically render you unaware of technology.
No, but it makes for a very non-representative sample. Consider the number of people who lack the administrative rights to install a toolbar on the computer they use most often.
Re:Google+ grows 43% in June
by jcampbell1 on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @04:21PM
(#4257664)
Compete's numbers are pretty good, you just have to understand the source. Digg showed more traffic, because Compete's datasource is US ISP logs, and any site with a digg button was added to digg's traffic.
The comparing reddit/digg on compete doesn't make much sense because of the digg button penetration. Just like comparing linkedin to google plus is stupid because many google properties make requests to plus.google.com.
Compete is a valuable tool, you just need to learn how to use it appropriately. Learn when it is reasonable to compare sites using it.
That's a reasonable explanation, but it's dishonest for Compete to put these numbers on a graph labelled "unique visitors". The Google+ poster didn't have any inkling about what the numbers represent.